AFL 2020 Round 6 Review: Upsets and comebacks

Who would’ve thought that all nine neutral clashes would fall the way of the ‘home’ sides? It was a weirdly normal result for an otherwise nonsensical season of footy. The outcome of Round 6 leaves new teams in the eight, powerhouses out of it and a change of the guard in premiership favouritism.

Geelong 11.7 (73) defeated Brisbane 6.10 (46)

For the first half of this game Brisbane looked in total control. They outran and outshone their older foes to take a sizeable lead into half time. But the Cats bounced back with a measured and brutal second half to secure their spot in the top four.

Patrick Dangerfield had a great night on Thursday (Herald Sun)

A combination of experience and emerging talent powered the Cats

For many years, Geelong relied on a hardened core of established stars to carry their side’s prospects. In certain wins during the 2020 season, younger members have covered for their teammates’ poor form. On Thursday night, Chris Scott witnessed a blend of the two combine to smack the Lions.

Pat Dangerfield, Tom Hawkins and Gary Ablett Jnr all wound back the clock to set up goals and dominate in the midfield and up forward. Ablett in particular was electric; after a mediocre first half he became involved in everything inside attacking 50. With the experienced trio were Sam Menegola, whose season continues to go from strength to strength, Sam Simpson and Gary Rohan. With Mark Blicavs controlling all defensive traffic, Geelong’s side is looking stronger by the week.

Geelong won off the back of some fine attacking work by Gary Ablett Jnr (Daily Telegraph)

What happens when Charlie isn’t on?

Brisbane’s forward line has looked versatile in the two years since Charlie Cameron’s arrival from Adelaide.

But Chris Scott planned to nullify Charlie, using Mark O’Connor and Jed Bews effectively to hold him to a solitary major. Without Cameron’s dominance up forward, only Cam Rayner could enjoy any success – his two goals kept Brisbane in with a chance during their third quarter demolition. Eric Hipwood couldn’t get away from Geelong’s tall defenders, while Dan McStay experienced a horror fall from grace alongside pal Lincoln McCarthy.

Verdict: Geelong are warming as flag favourites, yet face a big test against the Pies in Perth. Brisbane will be ok, but their forward line is their major concern.

Collingwood 8.11 (59) defeated Hawthorn 3.9 (27)

The Pies faced a nervy match up against the Hawks, who held the wood over them in recent clashes. However, Collingwood’s rejuvenated side flipped the tables on Alastair Clarkson’s men and recorded a solid 32-point win.

Travis Varcoe rebounded well out of defending 50 (AAP: Brendon Thorne)

New inclusions and changes revamp the Pies

It’s rare to say Alastair Clarkson has been out-coached. But on Friday, Nathan Buckley trumped him.

Bringing in attacking young defender Isaac Quaynor alongside debutants Atu Bosenavulagi and Will Kelly proved a masterstroke – the former was brilliant in rebounding, Bosenavulagi dazzled with his forward flair while Kelly added power and mobility before suffering a horror elbow injury.

But Buckley didn’t stop there; Jaidyn Stephenson was thrown to half back to add some versatility to his game, while Jamie Elliott flourished in the midfield. With Travis Varcoe slotting nicely across half back, Collingwood proved they can adapt to find their spark.

Can anyone help Sicily?

For the majority of Friday night, James Sicily was the only Hawk stopping Collingwood from trouncing their opponents.

He was huge, collecting 28 disposals and racking up 14 marks. The question was why didn’t he get switched onto the dangerous Brody Mihocek? James Frawley and Ben McEvoy struggled down back, and it was only Sicily who could cut off Collingwood attacks. Ben Stratton looked woefully out of form. It’s a major concern for Clarkson – he can’t keep relying on Sicily, Tom Mitchell and Isaac Smith if they are to improve.

Ben McEvoy had a poor night against Brodie Grundy (Fox Sports)

Verdict: It may have been understated but the Pies are slowly coming back to their best. Hawthorn are in disarray – is it time to bring in youth?

Fremantle 12.7 (79) defeated St Kilda 11.7 (73)

In almost unheard-of terms, Fremantle rebounded from a six-goal deficit to edge past the failing Saints at the death. St Kilda went from being in total control to slipping up due to Fremantle’s tenacity and desire for the four points.

The Dockers can rally past injuries

Fremantle were given no hope when they sat 36 points in arrears at quarter time. When ruckman Sean Darcy went down not long after and Nat Fyfe retired to the goal square with injury concerns, their issues became worse.

Nat Fyfe looked not quite right on Saturday (News Corp Australia/ Michael Klein)

But somehow Justin Longmuir’s men found spirit. The best part about it was that it came from a younger collective. Michael Walters led the way with 26 touches, while Lachie Schultz’ two goals (including the winner) and Matt Taberner’s efforts up forward went a long way to securing the win. Andrew Brayshaw put together another assured performance alongside the improving Darcy Tucker.

Not all is perfect at St Kilda

For the past fortnight the Saints were riding high off a rejuvenated list that was on the precipice of making a top four run.

But the Saints faltered in a game they had to win. St Kilda’s stars faded out of the game – Dan Butler went missing and Jade Gresham wasn’t as brutally effective as usual. In the final quarter comeback, it was only Jack Steele, Tim Membrey and Zak Jones who mustered any fight. If the Saints are to rebound, they need an even four quarter performance from their entire side.

Verdict: Fremantle can head back to WA full of confidence, while St Kilda will begin Round 7 with their tails between their legs.

St Kilda players left Metricon Stadium disgusted by their loss (The Courier)

West Coast 10.7 (67) defeated Adelaide 5.4 (34)

It may not have been clean or pretty, but the Eagles did what they had to do. Adelaide once again couldn’t find any targets up forward, leaving West Coast ample time to run away for another win.

The midfield is humming

It’s taken many weeks, but West Coast’s engine room is back to its best.

Tim Kelly dominated the Crows with 25 touches, but he was ably helped by Elliot Yeo, Jack Redden and Dom Sheed. Andrew Gaff was selfless in absorbing a tag and aiding his flourishing teammates, who performed without captain Luke Shuey.

Nic Naitanui started off hot against Reilly O’Brien, but cooled down to narrowly take the points. The Eagles now look dangerous, as two consecutive wins proved their midfield is returning to its top-tier form.

West Coast were glad to have Jeremy McGovern back and firing

Some positives in another low week

Adelaide will continue to struggle in 2020. With Taylor Walker and Darcy Fogarty out, they have no key targets who can take a mark.

But there are some efforts that deserve recognition. Brodie Smith and Matt Crouch are getting their hands on the footy, while Ben Keays blanketed Gaff. Tom Doedee’s season is only getting better, as he is intercepting the ball beautifully.

Verdict: West Coast are firming as the team to beat. Adelaide need to scrap away and find a forward line balance that works.

Adelaide were left to trudge off once again (Photo by Jono Searle/AFL Photos/via Getty Images )

Melbourne 12.8 (80) defeated Gold Coast 9.9 (63)

Melbourne secured the four points they had to get. In a see-sawing contest, Gold Coast’s youthful brilliance nearly stole victory. But Simon Goodwin’s men were desperate when it counted to win a tight contest.

Melbourne’s engine room and inclusions do the job

Max Gawn has had a tough initiation as skipper, but his best on ground performance on Saturday was the catalyst for Melbourne’s win. Joined by Jack Viney and Clayton Oliver, who rebounded from their poor disposal efficiency against the Tigers, the Dees produced some mature football.

Harley Bennell celebrates his first goal in red and blue (Ryan Pierse/ Getty Images)

Christian Petracca continued to look dangerous all over the ground, while Mitch Hannan and Ed Langdon added some badly needed outside run. New inclusion Sam Weideman showed he should never have been left out of the side, kicking two goals and giving Melbourne the tall target they yearn for.

The Suns can take solace in some blistering youth

Many expected Gold Coast’s eye-popping young talent to dry up after Matt Rowell’s shoulder injury. The Suns knew better, giving Izak Rankine his debut game.

The lively forward lived up to the hype, booting a mesmerising snap goal with his first touch in footy. He went on to kick two more and keep his side in the goal-for-goal contest. With Lachie Weller, Touk Miller and Charlie Ballard all remaining steady, Rankine was allowed to roam and create, giving Gold Coast a new element that is dangerous in a different way.

Ben King had a quiet night compared to his usual standards (The Gold Coast Bulletin)

Verdict: Melbourne have learnt what works for them going forward, while Gold Coast can work on harnessing Rankine and co.

Essendon 9.13 (67) defeated North Melbourne 7.11 (53)

In a scrappy affair up north, Essendon steadied when it mattered to gain the upper hand over the Roos. It definitely wasn’t an eye-catching contest, but it highlighted the problems North Melbourne face going forward.

David Zaharakis returned to form on Saturday night (Matt Roberts/ AFL Photos)

Old and new talent stand up

Essendon needed new heroes. With Jake Stringer sidelined after his Collingwood heroics, it was David Zaharakis’ turn to put in an age-defying performance. His three goals proved the difference and added some running spark to the Bombers midfield and forward line.

Dylan Shiel was targeted by the Roos. In his absence, it was Andrew McGrath and Darcy Parish who controlled the centre bounces. Orazio Fantasia enjoyed an improved game off half-back, while Conor McKenna and Adam Saad connected beautifully to rebound off defensive 50.

Some positives and some negatives for North Melbourne

Rhyce Shaw would be left scratching his head at how to invigorate Ben Brown. The runner-up in last year’s Coleman Medal is bereft of all form, only kicking a goal on Saturday after the Sherrin fortuitously fell into his hands.

Robbie Tarrant was one of the few Roos to stand up (NMFC)

But on a better note, Cam Zurhaar gave an improved effort around the footy, imposing his will and solid frame on all Bombers who dared to stand in his way. Todd Goldstein had a great night rucking, while Luke McDonald tagged well for the second consecutive week and Jy Simpkin had another consistently strong game in the middle.

Verdict: Essendon have some toughness, but will be tested when they play more polished sides. North Melbourne are slowly coming along, but need some tall targets outside of Ben Brown. They are missing Nick Larkey big time.

Port Adelaide 9.9 (63) defeated GWS 6.10 (46)

It was the first time this season the Power got tested by a scrappy, low-scoring encounter. Coming off a disappointing loss to Brisbane, Ken Hinkley’s men steadied when it mattered to work past an off-song Giants’ outfit.

Robbie Gray has flown under the radar so far in 2020 (Racing and Sports)

Do Port Adelaide hold the best all-round side in the league?

After an important win on Sunday, Port Adelaide’s list is looking more solid by the week. Hinkley was able to drop Tom Rockliff and still get a rise in the middle from the likes of Dan Houston, Connor Rozee and Brad Ebert.

Robbie Gray only has to show flashes of brilliance, while Kane Farrell, Hamish Hartlett and Karl Amon have created a formidable running defensive unit that beats any other team’s half-backs. Sam Powell-Pepper is another player who doesn’t have to star, but adds grunt and power to a line-up bursting with talent.

Stars faded when it mattered

For the majority of Sunday’s clash, Lachie Whitfield, Nick Haynes and Toby Greene all starred. Stephen Coniglio had a strong day, but went missing when the match was on the line.

Shane Mumford (left) gave his all for the Giants (Getty Images)

But other known names in Josh Kelly and Callan Ward were nowhere to be seen when the game tightened up. Jeremy Finlayson and Harry Himmelberg weren’t as good as their barnstorming efforts last week, leaving GWS carrying too many passengers when the final quarter broke out.

Verdict: Port Adelaide’s tough win leaves them entrenched in the top four. GWS need consistency if they are to go one better this year.

Richmond 4.10 (34) defeated Sydney 3.8 (26)

In a snooze-fest impacted by heavy rain and sloppy skills, Richmond came out lucky to record a win. Sydney just couldn’t generate anything up forward and were too defensive in key moments to topple the scratchy Tigers.

Lesser known Tigers covered their stars

Halfway through the first quarter, it would’ve been hard to fathom that Richmond would stumble to such a low score.

But by the match’s end Richmond were lucky to escape with a win. With many established stars out, Dustin Martin and Tom Lynch also had shockers. It was Jayden Short, Kamdyn McIntosh and Kane Lambert who led the charge. They constantly rebounded off defensive fifty and proved tougher than the Swans in the contested ball situations.

Shai Bolton stood up and kicked a vital goal on Sunday (RTFC)

A solid back line but only one player forward

John Longmire didn’t get it right on Sunday. Bringing in Robbie Fox to take on Tom Lynch was a wise decision, but the Sydney coach was otherwise way too defensive.

He has a tough task playing with a forward line missing tall timber, but with Tom Papley leading the Coleman Medal race he could surely encourage his troops to be a little more aggressive in getting the ball to him? Callum Mills and Jake Lloyd are impressing down back, but if the Swans are to win games they need to help Papley out.

Many Sydney players hunted the footy but couldn’t get their hands on it (AAP)

Verdict: Richmond are hanging on by the skin of their teeth, while Sydney are falling away badly. It’ll be a marvellous effort if Papley brings home a Coleman in such a dysfunctional forward line.

Carlton 16.7 (103) defeated Western Bulldogs 7.9 (51)

In a complete contrast to the previous game, Carlton brought up the century in a wonderful four-quarter performance. They out-worked the Bulldogs all game and looked dangerous up forward to breach the top eight.

Carlton now loom as a finals chance (Chris Hyde/ Getty Images)

A plethora of Blues have improved

There’s a lot to like for Carlton.

Will Setterfield and Matt Kennedy played wonderful games in the middle, while Harry McKay returned to his prominent best up forward. Combined with Jack Martin, Eddie Betts and Levi Casboult, the Blues’ forward line is bursting with potential.

Michael Gibbons has come along as a superb midfield/ small forward, winning the hard balls and powering the midfield when Patrick Cripps has off nights. Jacob Weitering is right up there in All-Australian talks after accounting for Josh Schache easily. Alongside the improving Sam Petrevski-Seton and the ever-reliable Ed Curnow, Carlton are looking solid across the board.

A bunch of emerging Blues celebrate yet another goal (CBFC)

Not many shining lights for the Dogs

In a horror night at the office, only Bailey Smith and Tom Liberatore can really hold their heads high.

The pair matched Carlton’s intensity in the midfield battle, fighting hard for momentum late in the first half. Marcus Bontempelli and Tim English had inconsistent nights that suggested their best is not far away. The main issue was the Bulldogs’ forward line, which failed when coming under pressure from Carlton’s emerging defenders.

Verdict: Carlton have reason to believe a finals spot isn’t out of the question. The Bulldogs have been taken down a peg, and need a Plan B if they fail to out-work the opposition.

Did you enjoy this article?

If so, be sure to check out the other pieces available on ‘Stuck on the Bench’!

If you like what you see, you can also sign up your email to subscribe, so you are notified as soon as pieces are published!

AFL 2020 Round 6 Preview – A nation-wide weekend of season-defining contests

All sides are now out of Victoria. The national competition is truly seeping into the other states. The cut-and-thrust nature of the 2020 season means many teams have defining contests on the weekend. Footy fans will hopefully emerge out of Round 6 with more clarity as to who are the favourites and who are just pretenders.

Geelong v Brisbane

Thursday 7.40PM

SCG

Two in-form teams will face off at the neutral venue of the SCG. Brisbane now have premiership favouritism – this match-up against the Cats will truly determine whether they are worthy of the flag fancy label.

Who stops Charlie?

Last week it was Daniel McStay who found form for the Lions. It was a rare quiet night for star goal kicker Charlie Cameron – it is unlikely he will falter two games in a row.

Geelong’s defence is experienced and versatile. Mark Blicavs and Harry Taylor should cover the tall options, but they will have to scramble to find the right match-up for Cameron. Jed Bews is in form and should be given first crack on the speedster, but Jack Henry or Mark O’Connor could also be swung onto Cameron if the Lion gets away from them. If Bews can’t contain him, Charlie may become a massive headache for the Cats.

The Lions will be looking to stun the Cats again (Image: AAP)

Which midfield wins?

Thursday night will play host to the league’s best midfield on paper coming up against the competition’s in-form on-ball brigade.

Dayne Zorko returns to a group that consists of Brownlow Medal favourite Lachie Neale and his able assistant in Jarryd Lyons. With Jarrod Berry, Hugh McCluggage and Mitch Robinson waiting on the wing to influence the contest, they will have to prove themselves again when they face the likes of Patrick Dangerfield, Joel Selwood and Gary Ablett Jnr. The Cats now feature Brandan Parfitt, Cam Guthrie, Sam Menegola and Mitch Duncan to give them a balanced group who can severely challenge Brisbane’s hot form.

Tip: Expecting this one to go down to the wire considering both sides will take time to adjust to the SCG. Geelong’s experience will help lots, but if Brisbane follow their form then they should edge home. Lions by 12.

Geelong have elected to rest Jack Steven on Thursday (Triple M)

Collingwood v Hawthorn

Friday 7.50PM

Giants’ Stadium

The Collingwood and Hawthorn battle has been intriguing in recent years. While the Pies have risen up the ladder, the Hawks have dropped. Yet Alastair Clarkson’s men have managed to upset Collingwood often in the past two seasons. With the Magpies in disarray, this contest is season-defining.

Adam Treloar must be at his best to lead the Collingwood midfield forward (Zero Hanger)

Will a new inclusion change the Pies’ forward line?

In the past fortnight, Collingwood’s attacking group have stuttered and failed dismally. Mason Cox has struggled to find any form, while the likes of Jaidyn Stephenson, Jamie Elliott and Brody Mihocek have only performed in spurts.

To combat this, Nathan Buckley will introduce son-of-a-gun Will Kelly into the fold. Kelly is a wiry and athletic full forward who has enough pace and tricks to trouble Hawthorn’s forward line. If he can change the forward balance and take the pressure off the other struggling attackers then it could go a long way to Collingwood posting a winning score.

Can Jaeger do it again?

The Hawks had a dismal night last Sunday at the same ground. The Giants ran riot and made Hawthorn look slow.

Jaeger O’Meara was a lone hand in the losing cause, matching GWS’ strong midfield and keeping his side in the contest until the second half. Against a failing Collingwood midfield, he will have to be at his best again. If O’Meara can inspire Tom Mitchell and James Worpel into the game then the Hawks will have a chance of knocking off the Pies.

Hawthorn must rely on older hands like Jack Gunston on Friday (Image: Michael Klein/ News Corp Australia)

Tip: This could go either way. Hawthorn have the form to beat the Pies and slow them down. But in a season of upsets, Collingwood just may return to form and notch a much-needed win.

Fremantle v St Kilda

Saturday 12.35PM

Metricon Stadium

The Dockers are coming off their first win of the season and should be buoyed towards making it two on the trot. St Kilda are in great form, and need to win this clash if they are serious about playing finals footy.

Will Brayshaw continue to fill the hole?

Without Nat Fyfe, Fremantle needed a midfielder to emerge and step up.

In a topsy-turvy clash with the Crows, it was young Andrew Brayshaw who performed and led his side to victory.

No Nat Fyfe creates a gaping hole in Fremantle’s midfield

Coming up against a more confident team, Brayshaw and his Dockers must improve and be clean in the midfield if they are to consistently trouble the Saints’ defence. If Brayshaw can perform, star player Michael Walters can head forward more and create a forward line that is much more dangerous.

Marshall could have a field day

Dockers ruckmen Sean Darcy and Rory Lobb are both struggling at stoppages. St Kilda’s Rowan Marshall is in such good form that he is holding Patty Ryder out of the side. If he continues his dominant standard, he could destroy Fremantle’s ruck combo.

The thing about Marshall is that he is also a star goal kicker. When he drifts forward, Fremantle’s tall timber must stop his marking ability if they are to keep Marshall out of the game.

A new look St Kilda midfield could prove too much for the Dockers (Image: St Kilda FC)

Tip: Fremantle should give an improved performance, but they won’t match the Saints. St Kilda by 33.

West Coast v Adelaide

Saturday 3.05PM

The Gabba

The Eagles bounced back to form last week, while Adelaide let one slip away when they fell to the Dockers on Sunday.

Are the Eagles back?

It’s the question on everyone’s lips after last Saturday’s win.

The West Coast Eagles looked a changed team when they edged past the Swans. Many of their star players returned to form. But are they for real?

West Coast must prove they have awoken from their slumber. Against the bottom side, they simply must take the four points home. A loss here would send them spiralling back to square one – a win will set them up perfectly to return home.

Two clubs in need of a win will rely on their older players

Conversion is key for the Crows

Adelaide had every right to feel unlucky on Sunday.

Bad goal kicking meant bad football, and it ultimately cost the Crows during their third quarter surge. With the Crouch brothers finding form and Tom Doedee returning to his 2018 touch, Adelaide have the fire power to match good sides. But they must play perfectly and convert every chance they get if they are to topple the Eagles.

Tip: Adelaide may fight hard, but West Coast should win. Eagles by 40.

Melbourne v Gold Coast

Saturday 6.05PM

Giants’ Stadium

Both of these sides need a victory to get their season back on track.

Melbourne gave an improved effort when they fought hard against the Tigers, but they lacked the polish and commitment inside forward 50 when it mattered. Gold Coast are reeling after losing Matt Rowell, but their improvement should challenge the Demons.

Which forward can benefit from Petracca’s brilliance?

Melbourne simply need a decent attacker to capitalise on their midfield’s dominance.

While Max Gawn continues to control the ruck, and Clayton Oliver and Christian Petracca rise in value, the Demons must convert.

Jake Melksham is one of many Melbourne players who must improve (AFL)

Bayley Fritsch teases as the most likely option to kick a bag of goals, as Tom McDonald’s time up forward is failing and Jayden Hunt has lost all form. Fritsch is an accurate kick and a versatile player – his presence up forward could trouble any mid-sized Gold Coast defenders.

Can Day and King beat May and Lever?

With Gold Coast’s midfield hampered after last week, the strength of their forward line is critical.

Ben King and Sam Day have both been in great form – they were very important in showing up Geelong’s defence last Saturday. If they are to lead the Suns to another great win, they must continue to pop up and kick a couple of goals each.

The pair will have to play well if they are to beat Steven May and Jake Lever, who are both beginning to gel as a defensive combo. It’ll be an eye-catching match-up; the winner of the clash could be determined by this little battle.

Matt Rowell’s injury cruels the Suns (Image: Daniel Pockett/ Getty Images)

Tip: Who knows. If Melbourne turn up then it’s game on. There’s no way to predict how Gold Coast will react, so it’s time for the Demons to win. Dees by 8.

Essendon v North Melbourne

Saturday 7.40PM

Metricon Stadium

The Dons are now looking towards finals after upsetting the Pies. North Melbourne need to bounce back hard before their season falls by the wayside. Whoever wins takes a giant step forward in 2020.

The Bombers and Roos will collide once again in a hot encounter (Image: Hamish Blair/ AAP)

How to replace Stringer?

Jake Stringer was critical to Essendon’s gritty win last Friday night. The midfield/ forward kicked three majors and was the game’s best player. Now, he is out injured.

It may be time for the improving Darcy Parish to receive more midfield minutes while he continues to blossom into a wonderful player. Andrew McGrath and Dylan Shiel will also shoulder more of the burden if the Dons are to win the midfield battle and then kick some vital goals up forward. Anthony McDonald-Tipungwuti must also become more consistent in Stringer’s absence.

Can North’s forwards find their fire?

The Roos are being barely held together by their defence. Robbie Tarrant has been in amazing form, but his midfield and forward compatriots have failed to fight with similar intensity.

With Ben Cunnington unlikely to play, Shaun Higgins and Jy Simpkin must display the Roos’ trademark toughness.

But the bigger issue is up forward. Ben Brown and Cameron Zurhaar must put pressure on – getting involved by doing the simple things will lead to goals and a win.

Tip: Expect North Melbourne to fight with renewed passion. But Essendon should hold on. Dons by 15.

Port Adelaide v GWS

Sunday 1.05PM

Metricon Stadium

This could well and truly be the match of the round.

Port Adelaide fell off their undefeated perch last week and need to make a statement. GWS are on a run and can solidify their top four aspirations with another big win on Sunday.

Port’s defence will be tested

Port Adelaide have an even array of performers across the board, but their pressing issue is down back.

Tom Jonas and Dan Houston are struggling to contain tall forwards, while Trent McKenzie’s fast start has petered out in recent weeks.

Against a star-studded GWS forward line, Tom Clurey must join them in giving an improved performance to nullify the Giants’ in-form players. Darcy Byrne-Jones and Hamish Hartlett must also stop the likes of Toby Greene from creating danger.

The Power must rebound from last week’s horror loss to the Lions (PAFC)

Haynes v Dixon

Last week, Charlie Dixon came up against the leading defender in the competition in Harris Andrews. He lost convincingly – now he faces Nick Haynes.

If Andrews is first, Haynes is second in the league. Dixon has a hard task ahead he is to stamp himself on the game and lead his Power to a needed victory. If he fails, Haynes has the ability to rebound and set up GWS attacks, which could prove too much for Port Adelaide’s weakened defence.

Tip: Port Adelaide will come out firing, but something about GWS looks settled. Giants by 21.

Richmond v Sydney

Sunday 3.35PM

The Gabba

After an injury-plagued win, Richmond leave their home state needing to improve without star personnel. Sydney fell away badly last week – both sides have motivation to win.

Is Balta the answer down back?

The Tigers have many star players out.

Dion Prestia, Tom Lynch, Toby Nankervis and Trent Cotchin should all miss. But Noah Balta’s return to the side last week changed the dynamic of their defence. He intercepted many forays forward and rebounded with pace and athleticism. In a team still missing Alex Rance’s influence, Balta could become a key pillar down back to inspiring the yellow and black to follow the Richmond way.

Kennedy and Parker or Dusty and Lambert?

Both midfields are not quite at their best.

Sydney’s on-ball assortment aged and relying on Josh Kennedy and Luke Parker to lead the way and reignite their old flames. Dustin Martin and Kane Lambert must have big games to replace Cotchin and Prestia’s influence.

Dusty has to bring the fire on Sunday to help his young Tigers (Image: Michael Klein/ News Corp Australia)

Whoever wins this skirmish can dictate the game’s momentum and set up attacks for their side. It looms as a defining aspect.

Tip: Sydney may enjoy lining up against Richmond, but they will have to step up the intensity to have a chance. Tigers by 30.

Carlton v Western Bulldogs

Sunday 6.45PM

Metricon Stadium

Carlton must prove last week’s first half against the Saints was an aberration. To do so, they need to upset an improving Bulldogs line up.

Will the Blues forwards fire?

Much was made of Levi Casboult and Mitch McGovern leading the Carlton fightback this season. Their Round 5 effort was insipid.

If Carlton are to trouble Alex Keath and Zaine Cordy, then their tall forwards must lead the charge. Jack Martin and Eddie Betts will be ready to crumb at their feet if they can bring the ball to ground, but their game plan is reliant on Casboult and McGovern performing.

Can the Blues stop the Bont? (Image: Quinn Rooney)

Was Bruce’s magic a one-time thing?

Josh Bruce destroyed the Roos last week.

His six goals lit up Marvel Stadium and changed the nature of their forward line. With Bruce firing in the absence of Aaron Naughton and Sam Lloyd, he makes the Bulldogs much more potent.

The key is consistency. If Bruce can find his feet and produce a season of constant brilliance, then the Dogs could keep shooting up the ladder.

Tip: Carlton will fight hard, but the Bulldogs should prove too strong. As usual, the Blues could surprise us all again though. Dogs by 17.

Did you enjoy this article?

If so, be sure to check out the other pieces available on ‘Stuck on the Bench’!

If you like what you see, you can also sign up your email to subscribe, so you are notified as soon as pieces are published!

The perfect storm – a history of the enigmatic Cam Newton

How important is culture?

Two forces will collide in the coming months when the charismatic Cam Newton touches down on a cleaned-out New England roster.

In the 2020 off-season, the league was shaken by a plethora of trade moves. The signings that caused the largest ripples through America were that of Tom Brady and his retired pal Rob Gronkowski at Tampa Bay. The pair are arguably two of the sport’s greatest players, having been part of New England’s dynasty since the turn of the century.

Patriots’ coach Bill Belichick was left scrambling for options to replace Brady; his search looked to be an empty one. The Boston-based side were rumoured to be on the hunt for ex-Tampa Bay QB Jameis Winston in a swap deal for Brady. When Winston joined New Orleans instead, New England were stranded without a big-name QB.  

It took until June for New England to find their fit. Cam Newton is an undeniably talented prospect. For one season he was the league’s brightest star; his fall from grace makes this next chapter of his career so intriguing. To return to the top, he will have to fit into the selfless atmosphere that surrounds Foxborough, Massachusetts.

When Cam Newton first burst onto the NFL scene, he was a breath of fresh air.

Coming in at pick number one in the 2011 draft, no one expected Newton to rival the experienced quarterbacks that filled the league so quickly. The era was typified by the reliable Peyton Manning and Tom Brady – two of the game’s greatest throwers who did the simple things right. Incredibly right. Newton was bringing his own straw to the competition; his flair shook everything up.

A product of Auburn University, he became the first graduate from the institution to go at pick one since Aundray Bruce in 1988. His college life wasn’t without controversy – a bribery scandal involving his father, who was a former safety himself in the 1990s, threatened to derail Cam’s path to the NFL. When he finally made it, the pressure was heaped on Newton’s muscular shoulders to perform. He worked like crazy to prepare for his rookie season.

‘Superman’ Cam in action during the 2011 pre-season (Photo by Streeter Lecka/Getty Images)

In the months leading up to the 2011 draft, the soon-to-be Carolina Panther enlisted the guidance of famous quarterback trainer George Whitfield Jnr. Whitfield Jnr was brought in to add the finishing touches – he is known for helping develop successful Pittsburgh Steelers QB Ben Roethlisberger. After being selected at pick one, the NFL went into a five-month lockout over a failed collective bargaining agreement. While the pre-season was halted, Newton trained for up to 12 hours a day in Florida with ex-Panthers thrower Chris Weinke. Weinke had been a part of Carolina’s lean patch in the years leading up to 2011. His tutelage of the next generation ensured the upcoming season began a change in fortunes.

Newton wasn’t expected to be a flashy newcomer. Carolina owner Jerry Richardson asked him to refrain from growing his hair longer and adding tattoos or piercings to his appearance – it was clear from the outset the Panthers wanted a trustworthy thrower. Newton accepted the terms, but he was never going to dial back his flair. The Panthers had unwittingly signed a thrower who wasn’t confined to the clean and safe game style of Brady or Manning. Cam Newton was a risk-taker.

Debuting in September 2011, Newton announced himself to the NFL. He became the first rookie to throw for over 400 yards in his debut game – he threw for 422 yards (including two touchdowns) while also rushing separately into the end zone. A week later he broke another record, becoming the first player to start their career with two 400-yard passing games.

It was clear early on that Newton was not in the same mould as Peyton or Brady. The latter were slow movers who sat back and picked off passes by spying gaps in the defence. Newton may not have been as calculating as his superiors, but playing on instinct and talent threw sides off kilter. He may not have looked it, but Newton was deceptively quick and agile for his 195cm frame. Newton was meant to be a dinosaur; a sluggish train who sat back and unleashed cannon passes downfield. Instead, he was dynamic, able to break through tackles and rush in touchdowns. By December, he had broken the NFL record for most rushing touchdowns by a quarterback when he strolled in for three scores against Tampa Bay. Fast-forward to New Year’s Day in 2012 and he had become the first rookie QB to throw over 4,000 yards. Did I mention he could also become a receiver at will too? It’s safe to say Newton was the complete package.

Newton’s breakout season gave him numerous accolades – he was handed two separate Rookie of the Year awards, and made the cut for the 2012 Pro Bowl. He had already earnt the nickname ‘Superman’ for his flashy touchdown celebrations, and he had started a Carolina ritual of giving away the ball to a lucky fan when his side reached the endzone. In no way was Newton the next heir to the Brady throne. He was Cam.

One knock on Newton’s game as he continued to develop in the NFL was his inaccuracy. When he chose to throw, he had a high rate of interceptions. It was the only dent on an extremely talented quarterback who shouldered the fortunes of his franchise each week. But his ability to improve was about to be sorely tested.

The ‘dab’ that typified Cam Newton’s exuberance

After adjusting to the different tactics that teams schemed against him in 2012 and 2013, Newton faced numerous injuries during the 2014 season. A pre-season surgery sought to fix an ankle problem he had dealt with since his time at Auburn. A brutal collision in a pre-season game saw him sustain a rib fracture. Upon returning, he began to show clear improvement in terms of throwing choice and execution. Just as he sat primed to lead his Panthers into a second consecutive playoff run, he was involved in a car crash and broke two vertebrae in his lower back. Newton would return to help his side into the second week of the post-season, but even the brilliance of Superman couldn’t come back from such a tough season.

But as they say, you have to endure the rain to enjoy the sun. Newton’s summer of sunshine came in 2015.

Re-negotiating his contract at the season’s start, Carolina ended up timing their re-signing perfectly. Newton started off leading his side to a 3-0 start – his performances drew praise from many experts who noticed his astute passing and wise decision-making when faced with blitzing defences. The Panthers won for the first time in Seattle to kickstart a season that would see them breeze into the Super Bowl. After 12 weeks they sat undefeated – Newton had joined Brady as being the only player to be named offensive player of the week three times in five weeks. The Panthers had a 15-1 record going into the playoffs, and smacked Arizona 49-15 to set up a date with the best defence in the league. He had created ripples in America’s sporting culture by popularising the ‘dab’ as a celebration for touchdowns. Avid NFL fans couldn’t get enough of ‘Superman’ Cam – the Lombardi Trophy was his for the taking.

Having blitzed Brady’s play of the week record, Newton had surpassed one of his contemporaries. To win the Super Bowl and clinch a championship, Newton now had to overcome the other throwing forefather in Peyton Manning and his Denver Broncos.

On the eve of Super Bowl 50, Newton became the 2015 league MVP. From his dab celebrations to his undeniable talent, the NFL’s fiftieth season revolved around Cam Newton. The Denver Broncos arrived ready to bring him down.

Led by Super Bowl MVP Von Miller, the Broncos performed a miracle. Newton hadn’t been stopped all year – six sacks, two fumbles and an interception saw the underdogs snatch a 24-10 win. Manning, although being on the winning side, had a similarly shocking day. Arguably one of the greatest individual seasons in the NFL came crashing down under glorious Santa Clara skies. ‘Superman’ had met his Kryptonite.

A decisive fumble that cost Carolina the Super Bowl (Image by Richard Mackson)

In the years that followed this dream-crushing loss, Newton never rediscovered his scintillating 2015 touch. He threatened to break out again at times, but shoulder injuries restricted his multi-faceted game from truly flourishing. By the end of the 2019/20 season, Carolina made the tough decision to let their fallen star go after he had struggled with a foot fracture.

Cast out into the wilderness, Newton’s YouTube channel detailed the work he put in to recover. ‘Superman’ had starred in the system, only to be chewed up and spat out. Now he wanted a shot at redemption.

Newton faces a new challenge at the imposing New England roster (Image by Jeff Siner)

It took until June, but Newton finally found a home at New England. In a side that is well-known for putting the collective before themselves, Newton will face a tantalising season trying to fit into the different culture. Bill Belichick and the Pats have nothing to lose – they snatched him for a bargain, and can only seek to gain from a fit Cam Newton. If ‘Superman’ is uninjured and can recreate just a sliver of what he produced in 2015, New England’s dynasty may not be over yet. It may just grow legs and waltz on into the endzone more often. This time with a dab and a dash of flair.

Did you enjoy this article?

If so, be sure to check out the other pieces available on ‘Stuck on the Bench’!

If you like what you see, you can also sign up your email to subscribe, so you are notified as soon as pieces are published!

AFL 2020 Round 5 Review: Returning to form or losing touch?

Football has now wrapped up in Victoria for the foreseeable future. Round 5 gave some of the competition’s heavyweights chances to notch much needed wins, while losses deflated other sides’ bubbles. Read through to see how your team is tracking in season 2020.

Jarryn Geary returned to smother Sam Docherty (Michael Klein/ News Corp Australia)

Carlton 8.7 (55) defeated by St Kilda 11.7 (73)

Brought forward to Thursday night, the Marvel Stadium clash between these two improving teams didn’t disappoint. St Kilda started off hot and looked the goods, before a spirited Carlton comeback fell a tad short.

Steele, King and Geary blanketed the Blues’ big guns

Saints coach Brett Ratten planned well for Carlton.

Knowing that Patrick Cripps and Jacob Weitering were both decisive factors for the Blues, Ratten plunked tagger Jack Steele on the former while backing in the young Max King to kick goals on Weitering. Both delivered – Steele notched 23 touches while taking Cripps out of the game for the first half (he arguably should have been left on him to quell any second half influence) and King slotted two goals and set up another in a handy performance.

But Ratten didn’t stop there. Carlton co-skipper Sam Docherty had flourished since returning from injury, so St Kilda captain Jarryn Geary was brought back to play a defensive forward role on the Blue. This paid immense dividends – Geary slotted two goals and took a handful of other decisive marks to hold Docherty accountable.

Boom recruits propel both sides forward

When the going gets tough, St Kilda and Carlton both have new players who make the difference.

Setting the tone for a first half Saints onslaught was Dan Butler, who once again put in an electric performance up forward. He may not have gathered as many disposals as other weeks, but he made them count by converting them into two majors.

Jack Martin has been an impressive recruit for the Blues (Carlton FC)

Needing a spark, Carlton turned to ex-Sun Jack Martin – he delivered in spades. He was clearly Carlton’s best, booting a goal while lighting up the half-forward line. When moved into the middle, he often dashed out of packs and set up direct forays into their tall targets. He may not be the best Martin in the league, but he is in red hot form for his new club.

Verdict: St Kilda continue to impress as a finals prospect. Carlton need to start off better, for once they settle into they are a much improved team.

Collingwood 7.6 (48) defeated by Essendon 10.3 (63)

It was a week full of turmoil for both teams, but it was the Bombers who came out best. After a slow start, they recovered in the wet to outwork the Pies and post a wonderful Friday night win.

The injured Stringer show leads his team

Always a tantalising prospect, Jake Stringer produced the goods against Collingwood.

Having to step up in the midfield to replace the suspended Zach Merrett, Stringer gave a virtuoso performance. He often burst out of the middle to send long bombs into the forward line, and then went forward to kick three decisive goals himself.

Jake Stringer was everywhere on Friday night before injuring his ankle (Michael Klein/ News Corp Australia)

Stringer may have finished the game with a serious ankle injury, but he was influential in inspiring teammates Dylan Shiel (29 touches) and Anthony McDonald-Tipungwuti (2 goals). The on-ball brigade of the Bombers was also boosted by Andrew Phillips – the ex-Blue managed to nullify much of Brodie Grundy’s impact at ground level.

The Pies must fix a dysfunctional forward line

It’s hard to believe Collingwood’s forward line was so potent just two years ago.

On Friday, it seemed an age since the black and white attack were propelling their side into a Grand Final. Jaidyn Stephenson continued his trend of starting strong and disappearing – he was one of the few to turn up in the latter stages with an improved last quarter. Will Hoskin-Elliott, Jamie Elliott, Brody Mihocek, Mason Cox and Callum Brown were all unsighted, giving Essendon’s defence a golden chance to rebound with ease.

Collingwood may be undermanned, but there is no excuse for their slow and disorganised forward line. If they are to get back on the board interstate, they must fix their attacking group to get the scoreboard ticking over.

Rupert Wills is one of many Pies who need to lift

Verdict: Essendon are gritting their teeth and producing solid wins in a difficult time, while Collingwood must find some grit and organisation of their own if they are to avoid a slump.

West Coast 11.11 (77) defeated Sydney 6.7 (43)

It was a sound return to form for the underperforming Eagles, as they finally broke through for their first win since the COVID-enforced break. There were shades of their 2018 selves in the second half, as they overran a brave Swans outfit who quickly crumbled under the pressure.

Fallen stars return to form

In the past few weeks, West Coast haven’t had many established players stand up.

On Saturday, Elliot Yeo, Jamie Cripps and Tim Kelly all gave their best performances of the season so far. Yeo was instrumental in the middle, Cripps was dangerous with two goals up forward and Kelly began breaking tackles and wreaking havoc.

With captain Luke Shuey falling to a hamstring injury early in the match, the experienced trio were critical to West Coast’s breakthrough win – their influence helped young guns Oscar Allen and Jake Waterman get free and kick some vital goals.

The Eagles celebrate a much-needed win (Bradley Kanaris/ Getty Images)

The Sydney tall timber is shaky

With Lance Franklin, Sam Naismith and Callum Sinclair all missing on Saturday, Sydney were exploited by the tall Eagles. Nic Naitanui dominated in the ruck against Aliir Aliir, winning hit outs with ease and controlling the clearance battle.

Hayden McLean tried valiantly up forward but was constantly double teamed by strong defenders, while Dane Rampe had his hands full with Josh Kennedy, Jack Darling and Allen. The experienced hands of Josh Kennedy, Luke Parker and Jake Lloyd all fought hard to keep their side in the match, but the Swans were always going to be vulnerable coming up against the strong spine of the Eagles.

Verdict: The Eagles may be back in a big way, with an open run in the next few matches giving them a chance to re-enter flag talks. Sydney are onto something, but lack the personnel currently to make a finals run.

Aliir Aliir and Hayden McLean (right) had a tough day against Nic Naitanui

Geelong 13.11 (89) defeated Gold Coast 8.4 (52)

The Cats simply had to win for their milestone men. Joel Selwood and Gary Ablett Jnr celebrated their 300th and 350th games respectively in style, as Geelong bounced away from the valiant Suns to notch another critical win.

In a milestone game, it was the young chargers who performed

It may have been all about Selwood and Ablett, but the win came courtesy of an even spread of younger performers breaking through at AFL level.

Ablett and Selwood walk off arm in arm after their milestone win (Daily Mercury)

Brandan Parfitt continued his strong year with another telling day at the office. Mitch Duncan excelled in the second half and Sam Menegola was a presence all day. With Tom Hawkins finding some form up forward, the Cats looked much more dangerous when the lesser names did the job. Zach Tuohy is a very underrated rebounding defender – alongside Menegola and Duncan he adds polish and attack to Geelong’s forward 50 entries.

They may be Rowell-less, but the Suns have enough to push

It was a horror start for the Suns. All the talk surrounded Matt Rowell and his match-up with the older guard of Geelong stars. A shoulder injury in the opening minutes ruined his debut season.

Matt Rowell looks despondent after a suspected dislocated shoulder (Michael Klein/ News Corp Australia)

But all was not lost for Gold Coast. Ben King continued his superb start to the season with three impressive goals, ably supported by Sam Day’s two. Lachie Weller, Hugh Greenwood and David Swallow all picked up the slack in the middle to lead their younger troops forward. It was two high draft picks in Noah Anderson and Jack Bowes who shone against a strong opponent to prove the Suns aren’t totally reliant on Rowell – his presence in the second half could have resulted in a different finish though.

Verdict: Geelong have the building blocks to launch a top eight assault. Gold Coast lost no respect – their list bats deeper than we all realised.

Western Bulldogs 13.9 (87) defeated North Melbourne 5.8 (38)

In an important Saturday night clash, it was the Dogs who turned up hungrier. They benefited from a sustained run of form – the Roos looked slow when they didn’t win the contested ball.

Bruce stands up

In my preview, I mentioned that the Bulldogs needed a forward to stand up in the absence of Aaron Naughton and Sam Lloyd. The answer came in ex-Saint Josh Bruce. He was everywhere, handling Robbie Tarrant and Josh Walker with ease to boot six goals.

Josh Bruce (left) dominated the Roos on Saturday night (Herald Sun)

In a forward line needing leaders, Mitch Wallis paved the way with two clever goals, while Josh Schache (2 goals) came into the side and supported Bruce perfectly. Now Bruce must prove this was no bolt of lightning – he has the game to become the key forward the Bulldogs need; his Saturday night performance teases to be the start of a great patch.

The banged-up Roos must play their cards right

North Melbourne have plenty of talented players who can leverage them to wins. But the way they were handled on Saturday night gave them no hope of taking home the four points.

Ben Cunnington was played while clearly unfit, and the Roos suffered because of it. He had no impact and ended up on the bench in the final quarter. Todd Goldstein can’t be expected to continue rucking alone for entire matches when he is only getting older – Tim English finished off strongly to split the points.

Young guns Tarryn Thomas and Bailey Smith both went off injured after dizzying knocks ruled them out. The one positive for North Melbourne is the consistency of Jy Simpkin, who is becoming their leading midfielder very quickly.

Young Roos gun Tarryn Thomas comes crashing back down to earth (North Melbourne FC)

Verdict: The Dogs could be one of 2020’s better sides if they keep improving. North Melbourne have taken a big step back, and need to regroup if they are to post wins in the coming rounds.

Brisbane 12.13 (85) defeated Port Adelaide 6.12 (48)

It was a highly-anticipated top of the table clash in front of a decent Gabba crowd. In the end, Brisbane’s sparkling second quarter run saw them take the points easily, instating themselves as current flag favourites over a Power side who weren’t at their best.

Andrews wins the battle

In a massive clash of in-form talls, Brisbane’s Harris Andrews delivered in spades. He blanketed Port Adelaide forward Charlie Dixon, holding him goalless and taking countless intercept marks himself. It was a huge win for the young star, and proves he is arguably the best tall defender in the league.

With the continued run of hot form from Lachie Neale and Hugh McCluggage, the Lions have a core group of consistent performers. When Jarryd Lyons and Daniel McStay join the party like they did on Saturday, the Lions look scarily good.

Brisbane brought their fire and passion with them on Saturday night (Brisbane Lions FC)

Youngsters salvage a bleak night

It may have been a horror show for the Power, but some high draft picks can hold their heads high. Zak Butters was everywhere, bravely flying into packs and putting in maximum effort to give his side a slim chance at a comeback. His two goals were brilliant – he is blossoming in his second year.

Connor Rozee once again showed flashes of brilliance, including a terrific snap goal – he may not have been as productive as Butters, but he shows promise in the middle.

With Travis Boak always performing well, this young crop of stars can help Port Adelaide produce more consistent footy in the coming weeks.

Verdict: Brisbane are flying high with an improving group of youthful stars. Port Adelaide may not be the best side in the competition, but they’ll beat many others.

High draft pick Zak Butters is making a name for himself at Port Adelaide (PAFC)

Adelaide 4.10 (34) defeated by Fremantle 8.6 (54)

It may not have inspired many, but this low-scoring contest went down to the final ten minutes. If Adelaide hadn’t of missed their chances, they may well have run over the top of the fast-starting Dockers. But it wasn’t to be as Fremantle flexed their muscles for their first win in 2020.

Poor kicking doesn’t hide the fact the Crows have found some talent

Adelaide had a golden opportunity to come back and snatch the lead from Freo halfway through the third term. Led ably by the Crouch brothers and Brodie Smith, they had all the play, only to miss many easy set shots.

Reilly O’Brien (left) needs to lift his team up to higher standards

In this period of frustration, Adelaide can be excited about the prospect of young Shane McAdam. The forward lit up the Crows’ attacking fifty, becoming the focal point in the final term. He possesses an innate ability to create something out of nothing, and launched for many marks in the second half. In a long season, Adelaide can look towards putting games into McAdam.

When Fyfe falls, Brayshaw steps up

Fremantle were in strife without their champion captain Nat Fyfe. Freo coach Justin Longmuir desperately needed more people to cover his absence – gifting a full game in the midfield to Andrew Brayshaw reaped rich rewards.

The emerging prospect had a career best day, amassing 23 disposals and combining wonderfully with David Mundy and Michael Walters. With Fyfe not expected back anytime soon, Brayshaw’s development could be a silver lining.

Young Dockers look relieved after finally getting on the board in 2020 (Chris Hyde/ Getty Images)

Verdict: Adelaide missed their great chance to salvage the season, while Freo snatched a win that could reverse their current form.

Melbourne 8.4 (52) defeated by Richmond 12.7 (79)

In the final game at the MCG for some time, Melbourne brought a high level of intensity to start this Sunday match-up. For all of their effort, it just wasn’t to be – Richmond regained some of their famous form to leap to an injury that brought many worrying injuries.

Petracca, Fritsch and Pickett all give Melbourne fans some joy

2020 may not be going any better than last year’s fall from grace, but Dees supporters can find solace in the rapid development of some young guns.

Christian Petracca is coming along in leaps and bounds – he was the standout player in the first half as his strong frame and precision kicking stood out. Bayley Fritsch was once again vital up forward. Without him, the Dees would have had no avenues to the big sticks. When the ball went to ground, Kysaiah Pickett cracked in and became dangerous. He may be only games into his career, but Pickett holds a special touch when near the Sherrin.

Christian Petracca was a thorn in Richmond’s side at the MCG on Sunday (AFL)

Richmond finally win, but at what cost?

The Tigers simply had to win if they were to head to the Gold Coast with a chance of making the finals.

Led by the improved Dustin Martin and Kane Lambert, the reigning premiers bounced back, but lost many experienced hands for their victory.

Toby Nankervis and Dion Prestia could both be out for a while with ankle injuries, while captain Trent Cotchin’s hamstring injury should see him sidelined for the next few weeks. With David Astbury still out, Tom Lynch’s broken finger isn’t a helpful ailment going forward. For the first time in years, Richmond must bounce back from a cruel injury run if they are to continue their improving form.

Verdict: Melbourne are crying out for a tall forward to help a developing midfield. Richmond are coming, but injuries could send them crashing back down.

Richmond star Dion Prestia faces a stint on the sidelines after injuring his ankle on Sunday (AAP Image/Julian Smith)

GWS 13.5 (83) defeated Hawthorn 7.7 (49)

The last game of the round went the home side’s way, as the Giants started off strong and finished well to cruise to a second straight victory. Hawthorn rallied in the second term, but couldn’t match GWS when it mattered.

Who needs Cameron?

Reigning Coleman Medallist Jeremy Cameron isn’t anywhere near his best, but it didn’t matter for the Giants.

Harry Himmelberg and Jeremy Finlayson both carried the slack with eight goals between them. They were irresistible, both easily beating James Sicily and Ben McEvoy to power their team to an easy victory.

Toby Greene was one of many Giants to smack the Hawks (AAP Image/Lukas Coch)

It’s a good issue for the Giants to have – Cameron may be out of form, but he still squeezed through two majors late to tease for the upcoming weeks.

Passengers hurt the Hawks

The top end talent at Hawthorn is up there with the best in the league.

Jack Gunston is still a wonderfully crafty tall forward who can play multiple positions, while the return of Tom Mitchell and the renaissance of Isaac Smith gives the Hawks versatility. James Worpel is slowly starting to find his feet after his 2019 breakout effort. But the main star is Jaeger O’Meara. He was everywhere on Sunday, controlling the midfield and keeping his side in the game.

Outside of this core group, Hawthorn fall away quickly. The main challenge facing Alastair Clarkson in the coming season is finding role-players who can balance the side and make them an unstoppable force, again.

Hawthorn hero Jaeger O’Meara continues to excel in the brown and gold (Wikipedia)

Verdict: The Giants are very quickly back in the flag favouritism markets. Hawthorn may not be top-end this season, but they aren’t far off.

Did you enjoy this article?

If so, be sure to check out the other pieces available on ‘Stuck on the Bench’!

If you like what you see, you can also sign up your email to subscribe, so you are notified as soon as pieces are published!

AFL 2020 Round 5 Preview: Mixed fixtures and defining contests

The competition is still reeling after some mid-week blows. In the past few days alone, the fixture for the weekend has been changed and Australian state governments have threatened to block Victorian teams from travelling interstate for games. To top it off, COVID breaches are popping up like spot fires. It’s safe to say everyone needs the weekend of footy to kick off to distract us all from the administrative issues.

Carlton’s Levi Casboult should be primed to back up his dominant start to 2020 on Thursday night footy (Daniel Pockett/Getty Images)

Carlton v St Kilda

Thursday 7.40PM

Marvel Stadium

Originally meant to be pushed back to the latter stages of the round, St Kilda and Carlton are now rewarded for their recent strong form. Both are coming off wins that bolster hopes for the season ahead; another win tonight will inspire long-suffering fans that greener pastures are on the horizon.

Will Carlton’s new bunch of improved players continue to flourish?

In the early stages of the 2020 season, it was the recruits in Jack Martin and Eddie Betts who were at the forefront of supporters’ minds. Fast forward a few rounds and it is a crop of established Blues who are leading David Teague’s men up the ladder.

David Cuningham, Mitch McGovern, Levi Casboult, Michael Gibbons and Jacob Weitering have all been key players in the club’s past two victories. Cuningham and Gibbons have warmed up in the midfield, becoming important contested ball winners and helping Patrick Cripps out in the centre. McGovern and Casboult have finally come good to create a tantalising attacking six, while Weitering is blossoming into one of the competition’s best key defenders. If the Blues are to make it three straight wins, this core group need to continue tracking upwards in their development.

Can someone stop Dan Butler?

Just a year ago Richmond were content to let Dan Butler walk out. Believing in their overwhelming stock of emerging small forwards, the new Saint has made his old club pay in 2020.

Saints fans can dream if they beat the Blues (Michael Klein/ News Corp Australia)

After booting bags of goals against both the Bulldogs and the Pies, Butler saved his best for his former side. Three goals and some magical touches up forward sparked the Saints’ upset win, and has him firmly sitting within the current All-Australian side. No small defender has been able to stop him yet – can Carlton finally be the side to curb his influence?

Tip: Expect this match to go down to the wire for Carlton’s third successive match. They will continue to improve, but St Kilda should be too good when it counts. Saints by 9.

Collingwood v Essendon

Friday 7.50PM

MCG

Collingwood and Essendon matches are always intense contests. Throw in some MRP trouble, a week of COVID controversy and two heartbreaking losses the previous round, and this should make for a cracker. Both sides will be going in undermanned but raring to win. It deserves a crowd of 90,000, as it doesn’t get any more important than this.

Collingwood will be looking to Brody Mihocek to lead the Pies’ forward line (Daily Fantasy Rankings)

Can Collingwood plug the Howe hole?

The Magpies would have been shattered about stumbling in the final quarter against GWS last week, but the biggest loss from last Friday was the knee injury to Jeremy Howe. He was arguably Collingwood’s most in-form player, and filled an irreplaceable role intercepting across half-back. With Howe gone for the season, Nathan Buckley must find a suitable replacement.

It looks like Jack Madgen will be given first crack ahead of Matthew Scharenberg, Tom Langdon, Lynden Dunn and young Irish prospect Mark Keane. He has not been a great intercept player so far, so expect him (if selected) to free up Darcy Moore to play a more attacking game.

Will Essendon’s Merrett-less midfield hold their own?

Losing Zach Merrett was always going to hurt the Bombers. It stings a bit more that his absence occurs against a Collingwood midfield that sits as one of the league’s best. Although the Pies will be without star Steele Sidebottom, they still have enough firepower to scare Essendon.

John Worsfold will be looking to the likes of Jake Stringer, Darcy Parish, Andrew McGrath and Dylan Shiel to fill Merrett’s shoes. They will all need to be at their best if they are to shark Brodie Grundy’s taps and win enough of the ball in the middle to feed their forwards.

Jake Stringer has a big Friday night ahead of him (SEN)

Tip: This could be a sloppy one, especially if the MCG is coated with dew and moisture. Essendon will always provide a contest, but they may struggle to go with the Pies for four quarters unless they pull out a blinder. Collingwood by 20.

West Coast v Sydney

Saturday 1.45PM

Metricon Stadium

The Eagles will feel a slight bit more confident after their crunch-clash with the Tigers was rescheduled due to COVID restrictions. Instead, they’ll face the travelling Swans in a must-win match if they are to climb back into finals contention. Sydney, after eight days of rest, should give a better showing then their dismal effort against the Bulldogs last round.

The spotlight is on Jack Darling and Tim Kelly

There have been many poor performers in West Coast’s stuttering start to 2020. The 2018 premiers began the year as one of the flag favourites. Now, they need a win this week to avoid being wiped out of finals contention.

Two stars who have played well under expectations are Jack Darling and Tim Kelly. The former has barely kicked a goal or influenced a contest up forward, while Kelly is yet to settle into his new club and become productive in the midfield. With established players in Luke Shuey and Josh Kennedy starting to improve, Darling and Kelly joining in on the party would go a long way towards West Coast rediscovering some form.

Jeremy McGovern’s possible return from injury could benefit his side, including teammate Josh Kennedy (right) (Gary Day/ AAP)

Will Papley be a consistent force in the race for the Coleman Medal?

Tom Papley has gotten off to a terrific start in 2020. After trade table talk centred around a potential move to Carlton failed to gain legs, the small forward has hit the ground running for the Swans.

His peak came last week, where his four clever goals kept his side in the contest. With Lance Franklin and Sam Reid still out injured, the Swans are relying on Papley to take one of the opposition’s best defenders and run them ragged. To kick a winning score, Papley needs to be at his dominant best. If he keeps slotting goals, he could be an outsider for the Coleman Medal too.

Tip: This could go either way. It’s an incredibly hard game to tip, as both teams are unpredictable. Sydney could pull one out of the box, but West Coast are overdue for a win. Eagles by 15.

Swans hero Luke Parker will line up in game 200 on Saturday (Michael Dodge/ Getty Images)

Geelong v Gold Coast

Saturday 4.35PM

GMHBA Stadium

This is Gold Coast’s big test. After a barnstorming few weeks, Gold Coast’s young stars now must prove themselves against Geelong’s famous milestone men down at GMHBA Stadium. Far from Metricon Stadium, the Suns will need to be at their best if they are to cause an upset.

Can the Cats overcome their rustiness?

It’s a significant weekend for Geelong.

Both Joel Selwood and Gary Ablett Jnr celebrate massive games milestones. The premiership players will be looking for a memorable win. To do so, they must overcome their proteges.

Geelong legends Joel Selwood (middle) and Gary Ablett Jnr (right) will play their 300th and 350th games on Saturday

Selwood and Ablett need Patrick Dangerfield, as well as emerging stars in Cam Guthrie, Sam Menegola and Brandan Parfitt to get busy in the centre. Harry Taylor could be a welcome inclusion down back to counter Ben King and Sam Day, while Tom Hawkins needs to kick a bag. Following a sloppy win over the Dees, it’s time for Geelong to make a statement.

Are Rowell and Anderson as good as they’ve been built up to be?

The Gold Coast recruits have gained a fair bit of media time. Matt Rowell could have the Rising Star in the bag by Round 10, and maybe a first season Brownlow Medal if he keeps performing at this level. He has been the Suns’ best player in the middle, and will be gunning for a fourth straight best on ground effort against the Cats.

Alongside his buddy Noah Anderson, the pair have created a deadly midfield combo. Experienced hands in Touk Miller, David Swallow, Hugh Greenwood and Brandon Ellis watch on ready to provide assistance, but Rowell and Anderson are the keys to unleashing the next generation on the ageing Cats.

Gun recruits Matt Rowell (L) and Noah Anderson (R) face a tough test against the Cats (Scott Barbour/ AAP)

Tip: This all depends on which Geelong rocks up. If they warm to their home ground and take control early, then they should win. If they are slightly off, then the Suns are in good enough form to pounce. Cats by 29.

Western Bulldogs v North Melbourne

Saturday 7.40PM

Marvel Stadium

Both sides will go into this match-up intent on a brutal win. The two teams base their games on crash-and-bash contested footy, and won’t hold back. The Bulldogs can move further up the ladder and towards finals footy if they secure a third straight win, while North Melbourne need to follow on from their amazing last quarter on Sunday to build momentum.

Who will step up in the Bulldogs’ forward line?

The Bulldogs have been hit by injury in their attacking six. Aaron Naughton won’t be back anytime soon, and Sam Lloyd could miss this game after hurting himself against Sydney. Luke Beveridge will need to find scoring options fast, and a few choices could arise from the midfield.

Marcus Bontempelli has the potential to wreak havoc while resting forward. Mitch Wallis and Josh Bruce are due to come good and snag a few majors. If Tim English gets a minute up forward he could take a few towering marks. If push comes to shove, Zaine Cordy may be thrown forward in an attempt to get the scoreboard going. It’ll be a tough slog, but the Dogs need some scorers to pop up.

Can the Bont continue his superb form? (Herald Sun)

It’s time for Brown and Zurhaar to come good

If the Roos had unleashed their burst of scintillating attacking footy earlier last Sunday, they would have beaten the Hawks in the final moments.

The spotlight is on Ben Brown, who didn’t touch the ball until three quarter time last week. He has had a poor start to 2020 – some goals are desperately needed to inspire some confidence in the power forward. Cam Zurhaar’s influence has been quelled after his strong showing against the Giants. After a few quiet weeks, he must come to the fore and unleash his inner pressure beast.

Tip: Both teams play a similar style, so it’ll all come down to who’s in better form. The Bulldogs will have a hard time scoring, but North’s forwards won’t win unless they improve. Dogs by 13.

Todd Goldstein and Tim English will lock horns once again on Saturday night (Getty Images)

Brisbane v Port Adelaide

Saturday 7.40PM

The Gabba

This could well be the game of the round.

The Power and the Lions are the top two teams so far this season. Port Adelaide are still undefeated, but their record will come under trouble when they play Brisbane on the Lions’ home deck.

Stefan Martin is a chance to return for the Lions’ crunch clash against the Power (Getty Images)

Will the Lions rectify their waywardness?

Brisbane could have scampered away to a massive win against the Crows last week. They were all over the last-placed side, but unfortunately, they kept missing when it came to converting shots at goal.

Lachie Neale and Alex Witherden were the chief players to miscue their shots. With Brisbane generating many scoring attempts from their midfield, the pair must be on target if they are to put pressure on the Power early and snatch a win. They are good enough – it all comes down to execution.

Who wins – big Charlie or reliable Harris?

This is the biggest clash on the ground. Charlie Dixon is in serious form, and is the best tall forward this season. He comes off six goals and will now line up against Harris Andrews, who is one of the leading tall defenders.

Both are in good touch, meaning this match-up should be mesmerising. Whoever comes out on top in this battle will be instrumental in determining who wins.

Power fans will be hoping for more of this on the weekend (James Elsby/AFL Photos)

Tip: Splitting hairs on this one. Port are good enough to continue their streak, especially if Dixon is on fire. But Brisbane at home is a more trustworthy tip, so I’ll play it safe. Lions by 9.

Adelaide v Fremantle

Sunday 1.05PM

Metricon Stadium

It may be a snooze-fest for the rest of the competition, but this game is vitally important for both teams. The loser will be confined to the bottom of the ladder and without any points – it’ll be a long way back from there. The winner can build some momentum and hit the rest of the season with a tad more confidence.

Was last week’s third quarter a sign of things to come for Adelaide?

The Crows were facing trouble at half time last week. A sparkling third term, headlined by Taylor Walker’s two goals and two assists, got them right back into the game against one of the league’s best teams.

Leaders Taylor Walker (L) and Rory Sloane (R) are pivotal to their side’s chances (The Advertiser)

Adelaide’s veterans are critical to correcting the ship. It’ll be intriguing to see whether Bryce Gibbs, Matt Crouch and Paul Seedsman will be recalled. If so, it could go either way – they may settle the younger players and lead the Crows over the line, or they may be too out of touch to perform. Walker and Tom Lynch need to produce up forward if the Crows are to turn the corner.

Will Freo finally get lucky?

The Dockers will be without their best player in dual Brownlow Medallist Nat Fyfe. His hamstring injury will rule him out – the Dockers must produce something special if they are to finally win without him.

Fremantle have been within striking distance in every game they’ve played – multiple losses have been by single-digit margins. They are on the precipice of winning and leaping up the ladder; they must win here if they are to improve.

Freo must win without hero Nat Fyfe (AAP)

Tip: With Fyfe out and Sloane under an injury cloud, this match is wildly unpredictable. It all depends on which out-of-form players turn up. The Crows are a big chance to break their drought, but the Dockers deserve a win. Freo by 10.

Melbourne v Richmond

Sunday 3.35PM

MCG

Sunday’s match is a season defining clash if ever 2020 has seen one. Richmond have to win at the ‘G or else they are in serious trouble of missing the finals. Melbourne need to get a victory to stay away from the bottom four and keep the pressure off Simon Goodwin.

Are Brayshaw and Viney back?

In Melbourne’s slide down the ladder following their 2018 finals run, Max Gawn, Christian Petracca and Clayton Oliver have been constantly handy. They have done a lot of heavy lifting – now Angus Brayshaw and Jack Viney are starting to join the party.

Richmond will bounce back with a vengeance – the Demons midfield needs to be at their best if they are to beat a desperate Tigers centre group. Brayshaw’s two goals nearly got his side over the line last week, while Viney is regaining his status as a bull at centre bounces. They must give a good showing for the Dees to get up. They’re certainly good enough to win, but they yearn for an even showing.

Angus Brayshaw (L) is looking to continue his improving form (Getty Images)

When will Dusty and Riewoldt arrest their slump?

Premiership heroes Dustin Martin and Jack Riewoldt have been key villains in Richmond’s horror start to 2020. The pair have struggled to get the ball and dominate games like they are so used to doing.

For the Tigers to rejuvenate their season, Dusty and Jack need to find their feet quickly. They are leaders who have climbed the premiership mountain – it’s simply not good enough if they underperform for another week.

Tip: Melbourne will have plenty to fight for and will continue to improve. But this week’s not their time – Tigers by 30.

Tigers hero Jack Riewoldt should fire his side to a much-needed win on Sunday (Herald Sun)

GWS v Hawthorn

Sunday 6.10PM

Giants’ Stadium

An interesting match finishes off Round 5. GWS will be buoyed by last week’s gritty win over the Pies. Back at their home track, they have the chance to score a second win and fly up the ladder. Hawthorn were lucky to beat the Roos – a win here would convincingly set them up for 2020.

Is Toby Greene headed for a career-best season?

The notorious GWS star shot back into AFL stardom with a match-winning display against Collingwood. Toby Greene’s three goals were the difference, and he beat one of the league’s best defenders in Brayden Maynard.

Toby Greene (centre) can change the game quickly with his skill around goal (Mark Kolbe/ Getty Images)

His impact is required again. Hawthorn coach Alastair Clarkson will have plotted against the Giants to stem their running game. They’ll need star power to overcome the disciplined Hawks. Greene is the primary candidate to break out of Clarkson’s grip and win the Giants the match.

McEvoy and Sicily can claim a big scalp

Ben McEvoy may have had a slow start as a tall back, but he has now flourished at centre half-back. Combining with James Sicily, the pair have destroyed the likes of Ben Brown, Jack Riewoldt and Tom Lynch in the past weeks.

Ruckman-turned-defender Ben McEvoy faces a tough challenge on Sunday (TLA Worldwide)

The Hawthorn pair have a big task ahead in nullifying Jeremy Cameron and Jeremy Finlayson. Cameron is just starting to find his Coleman Medal-winning touch, and Finlayson has been consistently good all season. McEvoy must perform well for a third straight week, and needs Sicily to help him out if the Hawks are to stop GWS’ main goal-scoring sources and leave New South Wales with a win.

Tip: GWS look in better touch and ready to win again at home. But something about Clarkson, even when his team is out of form, has the air of an upset. He did it twice last year against the Giants, and he might just do it again here. Who knows? Hawks by 19.

Did you enjoy this article?

If so, be sure to check out the other pieces available on ‘Stuck on the Bench’!

If you like what you see, you can also sign up your email to subscribe, so you are notified as soon as pieces are published!

AFL 2020 Round 4 Review: Cliff-hangers and nailbiters

Round 4 teased to be a thrilling weekend full of close clashes and stunning upsets. It didn’t disappoint – four matches were decided by under a goal.

With next week’s matches up in the air, several teams wait with bated breath to see who they must beat in order to turn their season around.

After a tough week, Josh Kennedy couldn’t get the job done on Thursday night (AFL)

Sydney 5.9 (39) defeated by Western Bulldogs 10.7 (67)

The Bulldogs may well and truly be back.

After two horror losses in the opening rounds, the red, white and blue have rediscovered their brutal form. Sydney just didn’t turn up – an emotional week was capped off by a disappointing loss that doesn’t truly reflect their potential.

The Bulldogs’ midfield is clicking

It may not have been the centre group Luke Beveridge had in mind at the start of the season, but he has cobbled together a midfield that is flourishing.

Bailey Smith had another wonderful match flying through the centre and bringing an aggressive presence to stoppages, while Jack Macrae has benefited from Smith’s contested ball work to break free on the outside. Marcus Bontempelli had his best game of the year so far – his strength and talent in close was ably combined with his precision in uncontested situations to wreak havoc. Tom Liberatore continued his hard-nosed approach at the footy.

Pat Lipinski was a handy inclusion, while Toby McLean and Rhylee West both impressed in their spurts through the centre. Beveridge still has the calibre of Lachie Hunter, Josh Dunkley and Lin Jong on the sidelines; the Bulldogs’ on-ball brigade could become a scary prospect.

Mitch Wallis was one of many Bulldogs to perform in another great win (AFL)

Papley is paving the way

The Swans are missing Buddy Franklin – there’s no doubt about it. Sam Reid’s absence is also leaving a gaping hole in John Longmire’s tall forward stocks. But a much smaller presence is picking up the slack.

Tom Papley was electric on Thursday night, and nearly single-handedly dragged his side back into the match with his four goals. He has enough pace to burn off taller opponents, but his positioning and goal-sense make him a daunting opponent to defend due to his strong leading patterns. He temporarily led the Coleman Medal list – if he keeps chipping in with small bags of goals each week, he could be on his way to a breakout season.

Verdict: The Bulldogs are now back on track for the top eight. Sydney are doing their best despite the unlucky cards they are being dealt.

GWS 10.6 (66) defeated Collingwood 9.10 (64)

This match lived up to expectations.

GWS finally showed up to a match with intensity and grit – they may not have had the polish attached, but it was enough to out-work the Magpies. Collingwood had a rough night. They worked their way back into the match fantastically, yet couldn’t capitalise on their last quarter chances. When Jeremy Howe went down injured, the night turned sour quickly.

The grass is always Greene-r

GWS needed a spark up forward – it was common knowledge.

Many fans looked to 2019 Coleman Medallist Jeremy Cameron for the start of a form turnaround, but he only produced flashes of brilliance in between being well held by Darcy Moore. Instead, it was the returning Toby Greene who bucked the trend against Brayden Maynard.

Toby Greene celebrates one of his three goals (Mark Nolan/ AAP)

The Collingwood star defender has previously beaten Greene in their direct battles. But on Friday night the Giants’ forward was everywhere. He was out-pointing Maynard in marking battles, using his awareness to judge the ball’s flight to perfection. He was bobbing up in the middle of packs and snapping goals over his head. If he hadn’t of dished off an easy set shot to Cameron, Greene would have slotted four majors. But his influence was enough to rejuvenate GWS’ forward line and crack through Collingwood’s vaunted defence.

Did Collingwood learn anything from 2019?

For Pies fans, Friday night was eerily similar to last year’s Preliminary Final. A decent start gave them an early lead in a low-scoring first half, but a dismal third term saw them get blown away. GWS went harder at the ball, and scrapped for long enough to open up attacking options through the middle of the ground. Leon Cameron out-coached Nathan Buckley, and Collingwood looked out of the contest.

But in a mirror-image of last season, the Pies fought back late and had many chances to snatch victory. It was all too little too late – several behinds blew their chance at victory, and the black and white army were left rueing a reactive approach to GWS’ game plan.

Verdict: GWS can settle into the season now, while Collingwood should be fine, but they have to change their back line to cover for the irreplaceable Howe.

The moment all Collingwood supporters’ hearts dropped (Mark Nolan/ AAP)

Port Adelaide 13.11 (89) defeated West Coast 6.5 (41)

In an eagerly anticipated Gold Coast match-up, Port Adelaide proved they were a team full of consistency. West Coast slipped deeper in their well, and must win ASAP if they are to salvage a failing season.

Charlie Dixon is currently the best tall forward in the game

It’s taken a lot of time for Charlie Dixon to get an uninterrupted pre-season under his belt at Port Adelaide. When fit, he has always promised to explode in a storm of aggression, confidence and goals. He drips with presence, and has the ability to win a game off his own back.

With Jeremy McGovern still out for the Eagles, Dixon pounced. He smashed Tom Barrass, taking contested marks with ease and booting six majors. If Dixon is up and about, the Power look to be such a dynamic team. Could he be the key to a deep finals run?

Charlie Dixon is in imposing form (AFL Photos)

Shuey and Ryan are two of only a few brave souls

The longer West Coast’s season continues to spiral out of control, the more obvious it is to see who is performing, and who’s not.

Nic Naitanui was humbled in the ruck by ex-Eagle Scott Lycett, but new captain Luke Shuey fought through soreness to produce a wonderful effort. He was everywhere in close, and began to rally the rusty Tim Kelly out of his mire. Liam Ryan continued his dangerous form up forward, while Josh Kennedy booted four. Unfortunately, Jack Darling, Dom Sheed and the majority of West Coast’s back line are still woefully out of form.

Nic Naitanui had a tough ruck battle with Scott Lycett (Jono Searle/AFL Photos )

Verdict: Port Adelaide become more of a flag contender by the weeks. West Coast simply must win now to avoid embarrassment.

St Kilda 15.3 (93) defeated Richmond 10.7 (67)

The Saints came out firing at Marvel Stadium, and unleashed a withering burst of fast-paced footy on the hapless Tigers. Many Richmond flag stars looked slow and out of their depth, while St Kilda’s recruits continued to blossom.

St Kilda ran riot on Saturday arvo (Michael Klein/ News Corp Australia)

Dan Butler is making an early case for AA selection

It may be very early to be talking All-Australian potential, but ex-Tiger Dan Butler put in another influential performance on Saturday. To remind his old club that they slipped up in shipping him off to the Saints, Butler slotted three majors (including one terrific snap from the boundary) and was listed as the best player on the ground.

After dominating the Bulldogs and putting in an admirable effort in a loss to the Pies, Butler is currently one of the best small forwards roaming the AFL. If he continues this form, he may be elevated to AA selection by season’s end.

Nankervis was a good call

After Ivan Soldo failed to perform in the opening rounds, old-timer Toby Nankervis was recalled back into the Tigers line up.

Coming up against young gun Rowan Marshall, Nankervis thrived and was Richmond’s best player. He had 26 hit outs, 17 touches and a goal to mark a successful return to AFL level. The Tigers may have struggled lots over the past few weeks, but this call was spot on.

Verdict: St Kilda are good enough to reach the finals. Richmond, like the Eagles, need a win very soon to have any chance of turning their fortunes around.

Jack Riewoldt and his side are in desperate trouble (Michael Willson/ AFL Photos/ Getty Images)

Essendon 8.3 (51) defeated by Carlton 7.10 (52)

In a dour yet tight match at the ‘G, Carlton just managed to squeak past their old rivals. Jacob Townsend had a chance to be the hero, but his booming set shot fell just short of giving the Bombers another win.

McGrath and Parish are the future

Young duo Andrew McGrath and Darcy Parish were on fire on Saturday night. McGrath’s breakneck pace was everywhere – he could be seen often bursting out of packs all over the ground.

Parish’s goal sense when he pushes forward from the midfield is impressive. He is turning into a versatile gun who play in a similar vein to Jake Stringer. With these two firing, the pressure comes off of getting Dyson Heppell and David Zaharakis back and in form.

Anthony McDonald-Tipungwuti was hardly spotted on a quiet Saturday night (AAP Image/Julian Smith)

Sam Docherty is a star

Many people know this, but Sam Docherty is one of the competition’s best small defenders. He is only a few matches in after returning from multiple ACL injuries, yet he is bounding around the ground and controlling his defence.

He amassed 32 touches on Saturday night, and was one of his side’s best in a close finish. His ability to read the play and then rebound with skill is so vital for a young Carlton side thriving off his security and direction.

Verdict: Essendon need a more even contribution next week, while Carlton are showing signs of improvement.

Sam Docherty was a powerhouse down back for the Blues (The West Australian)

Gold Coast 10.4 (64) defeated Fremantle 8.3 (51)

Metricon Stadium is becoming a little fortress for the Suns. They won a third straight game against a defiant Fremantle side. Matt Rowell once again dominated in the midfield, while their other young stars performed well to triumph in a tough contest.

Gold Coast have real balance

One thing that is being made clear about Gold Coast is their even-spread of contributions. They have so many young kids that it’s hard to name them all, as Rowell and Noah Anderson are taking most of the plaudits. With experienced players in Hugh Greenwood, Brandon Ellis, Alex Sexton, Jarrod Witts, Touk Miller and Sam Day all providing superb support, the Suns have few gaps.

The Suns are made up of a blend of bursting youth and experience

Their forward line is ominous when Ben King backs up Day and Sexton, and Jack Lukosius tightens up their defence superbly. Don’t even get me started on their blossoming midfield.

Freo have no luck

Justin Longmuir has been dealt a tough hand in his first year in charge at the Dockers. He has tried his best, but some games just aren’t meant to be won.

The Dockers have fought hard in every match, going down late in the final term. Michael Walters and James Aish continue to perform in the middle, and Matt Taberner is having an influence up forward. But Nat Fyfe’s hamstring injury spells trouble – Freo are so close to breaking through for a win, and don’t deserve to be winless after four rounds.

Jesse Hogan must bring this intensity more often (AAP Image/Darren England)

Verdict: The Suns should be confident about beating anyone. Fremantle’s first win is just around the corner.

Brisbane 10.23 (83) defeated Adelaide 7.4 (46)

It wasn’t pretty, but Brisbane got the job done. Some sloppy kicking at goal restricted what could have been a big win. Adelaide deserved some justice after they showed good signs in an improved third quarter.

Charlie Cameron and Cam Rayner make up a versatile Brisbane forward line (The Roar)

McCluggage is moving up into the elite category fast

Hugh McCluggage was always a highly-touted young kid. His ability to break lines and distribute the ball with precision made him a mouth-watering prospect. He is now starting to deliver.

He was Brisbane’s best on Sunday, sprinting through packs and hitting targets regularly. In a side where Lachie Neale and Charlie Cameron are superstars, the rise of McCluggage could provide more depth to an improving Lions’ line-up.

Tex and Lynch could be warming up

At half-time the writing was on the wall for Adelaide. They were down by over 40 points and were looking at another soul-destroying smashing. Then, leaders Taylor Walker and Tom Lynch resurrected the Crows in the third term.

Walker kicked the first two goals of the half and then set up two more to become a livewire. Without Darcy Fogarty, he needed to step up and direct traffic. Lynch returned to his creative best, and the pair saved some face before slipping up in the final term.

Verdict: Brisbane are quickly becoming a classy side. Adelaide are still in trouble, but there are some good signs coming out of the Crows camp.

Adelaide struggled to stop Brisbane’s even contributors (NT News)

Melbourne 6.8 (44) defeated by Geelong 7.5 (47)

In a dull and lifeless MCG match, the Cats slowly managed to overcome the defiant Dees. Halfway through the last quarter, when Tom Hawkins steered through a cool set shot, Geelong looked home and hosed. But Simon Goodwin’s men had some fight in them – the contest went down to the last minute when an Adam Tomlinson shot flew just wayward.

Geelong’s second-string players are critical

Chris Scott would be rapt with the way his younger troops played. Brandon Parfitt, Cam Guthrie, Darcy Fort, Sam Menegola and Esava Ratugolea all performed when it mattered in the second half. For the first time in a while, the front liners in Pat Dangerfield, Gary Ablett, Joel Selwood and Tom Hawkins weren’t called upon to deliver the win in the final moments.

Scott now needs consistency from these contributors if they are to continue winning. It’s good signs, but they’ll be severely tested when they host the in-form Suns.

For once it wasn’t all up to Geelong’s Tom Hawkins on Sunday (AAP Image/Hamish Blair)

Melbourne’s big problem is the forward line

Simply put – Melbourne lost out when they let Jesse Hogan walk out the door. Sam Weideman and Tom McDonald haven’t been able to fill the void, meaning the Dees forward line is woefully undersized.

Melbourne’s back line is strengthening due to Jake Lever and Steven May getting a clear run without injury, while Clayton Oliver, Angus Brayshaw and Jack Viney are all holding their own in the middle. It’s down forward where they need help – especially in the tall forward area.

Verdict: Geelong are improved, but face a big couple of weeks before heading west. Melbourne need to move the ball quicker to help their undermanned attacking six.

Melbourne need to change their game plan fast (Richard Wainwright/ AAP)

Hawthorn 8.10 (58) defeated North Melbourne 8.6 (54)

In a topsy-turvy clash, the Hawks got away early and looked set to take the four points. Well-held all day, North Melbourne’s big names turned up in the last quarter. The game went down to the wire, but it was Hawthorn who held on to secure a tight win.

Mitchell Lewis’ return helped Hawthorn to a nervy win (Scott Barbour/ AAP)

Is Ben McEvoy one of the best key defenders going around?

Who would’ve thought after the first two rounds that Ben McEvoy would turn into an elite tall defender?

Since losing to Geelong, McEvoy has evolved, claiming two massive scalps in Tom Lynch and Ben Brown in successive weeks. The former ruckman held Brown to one possession at three quarter time – the runner up in last year’s Coleman Medal race finished with three touches and a goal courtesy of a late free kick. In a side full of disciplined performers, McEvoy is one of the best.

Higgins breaks the tag

Last week Shaun Higgins had his colours lowered courtesy of a Sydney tag. He had little influence and couldn’t find a way to get the ball.

Fast forward to Sunday and Higgins had done his homework. Hawthorn’s midfield tried to nullify any potential influence the veteran playmaker could have, but nothing worked. Higgins finished with 30 disposals and orchestrated many last quarter surges. With Ben Cunnington still in doubt with a niggling injury, Higgins must continue firing for his Roos.

North Melbourne need Ben Cunnington to return soon (AAP Image/Julian Smith)

Verdict: Hawks are sitting pretty in the four after another strong performance. North Melbourne are very close to finding form, but must be more consistent.

AFL 2020 Round 4 Preview: As unpredictable as can be

This current AFL season, in all of its madness, is clearing up after its murky beginnings.

The release of Round 6 fixtures and details of future WA hubs means the season is starting to take shape. For numerous teetering sides, Round 4 looms as a massive weekend for their 2020 fortunes. There are a raft of contests that could go either way.

Sydney v Western Bulldogs

Thursday 7.40PM

SCG

Last week’s results mean this clash intensifies.

Not long ago these two sides were meeting in a famous Grand Final. Now, they are both fighting to string early wins together to make a push for finals. Sydney have surprised; their young list is producing enough to hang in matches. The Bulldogs have found a renewed sense of vigour after last Friday night, and must match it if they are to have any chance of making it two in a row.

From left to right: Nick Blakey, Oliver Florent and Isaac Heeney all hold the key to Sydney’s future (Cameron Spencer/ AFL Photos/ Getty Images)

The battle of the tough mids

Sydney’s older core of stars in Josh Kennedy and Luke Parker fashioned a special four-quarter performance against the Roos last week. Coming up against one of the tougher midfields in the competition, Kennedy’s strength at the coalface and Parker’s industry led the Swans right over the top of the Shinboners. With Isaac Heeney coming into his own in the midfield, Sydney must replicate this superiority against the fiery Bulldogs.

Many of Sydney’s older stars are gone, but Josh Kennedy and Luke Parker remain (The Advertiser)

The boys from Footscray changed rapidly last week. Tom Liberatore was back in the side and the Dogs were tenacious around the ball. If both teams bring this renewed application to winning the contested ball, then this match should be a cracker.

Will the Bulldogs be able to break through Sydney’s defence?

Often an underrated line, Sydney’s back six are rock solid. Dane Rampe, Aliir Aliir and Callum Mills are one of the best groups of tall defenders in the competition, while Jake Lloyd and Robbie Fox are composed disposers of the footy coming out of the back 50. With the likes of Harry Cunningham and Oliver Florent also spending time off half back, the Swans have a trustworthy yet aggressive defence who are difficult to score against.

To win this game, the Bulldogs must find ways of breaching them. They rely heavily on their midfielders to push forward and kick goals, but Aaron Naughton, Mitch Wallis, Josh Bruce and Sam Lloyd must all contribute and wreak havoc against their reliable opponents. If they don’t, the scoreboard may dry up quicker than a puddle on a summer’s day.

Tip: Expecting another tight contest that could go either way. If Sydney play the way they did last week they should prove too good – just. Swans by 16.

Are the Bulldogs back? (Getty Images)

GWS v Collingwood

Friday 7.50PM

Giants’ Stadium

This match could be anything.

In a rematch of the crazy 2019 Preliminary Final, Collingwood will travel up to Western Sydney looking for revenge. They are in decent form to challenge the Giants, who will be fired up after a fortnight of pathetic performances. All roads point to this contest being intense and close. We’ll just have to wait and see which GWS comes out to play.

Collingwood will be looking to avenge that Prelim Final loss (Daniel Pockett/ Getty Images)

Can the Giants finally produce a hardened attack on the footy?

Halfway through last season, GWS came out amidst criticism to absolutely dismantle Collingwood. The black and white army were helpless as the likes of Stephen Coniglio, Josh Kelly, Lachie Whitfield and Jeremy Cameron all burst out of the blocks to set up a rampant win.

Now, the Giants need this effort again. They have come under fire for their weird attack on their opponents last week. To beat the Pies, they must be completely zoned in to winning the clearances and out-working Collingwood’s vaunted midfield. GWS rely on getting the ball to outside users like Heath Shaw and Whitfield, but they can’t do this if they aren’t winning it at the start.

Is GWS the only team who can break through Collingwood’s defence?

After last week’s miserly effort against the Saints, the Magpies’ mature back six were praised for keeping their three 2020 opponents to under 40 points each. Darcy Moore and Jordan Roughead have been superb against the competition’s tall forwards, but now they must do the job against Jeremy Finlayson and Jeremy Cameron. Both aren’t playing at their best; that means nothing when they have the talent to suddenly flick the switch.

Toby Greene shapes as a massive inclusion for the Giants (Sitthixay Ditthavong)

Brayden Maynard has been rock solid, but he will now get a tougher assignment on Toby Greene. Jeremy Howe’s ability to take intercept marks will also be put to the test against Harry Himmelberg. It’s a mouth-watering contest between the league’s best attack and defence.

Tip: This is another that can easily go either way. If the two sides play as they have in previous weeks then the Pies should get the job done, but GWS are extremely unpredictable. I’m going to go Collingwood by 25, but it all depends on the boys in orange.

GWS are yet to bounce back from their humiliating 2019 Grand Final day (SEN)

Port Adelaide v West Coast

Saturday 1.45PM

Metricon Stadium

It’s getting close to do-or-die for the Eagles.

They must win in Queensland if they are to have any chance of a finals spot, nonetheless a double chance. They have been disappointing so far – could a win against the competition’s leading team shock them into action?

This is Port’s test

The Power are currently atop the ladder, but they have had it rather easy. They easily dispatched a rusty Gold Coast in Round 1, and then returned from the hiatus to smack the wooden spoon favourites in Adelaide and edge past a defiant Fremantle. Despite West Coast’s poor recent form, their experienced midfield will put the Power to the test.

The Power have gotten off to a great start in 2020 (PAFC)

Power coach Ken Hinkley has his eyes on finals, and these sorts of games must be won if his side is to remain a threat going forward. They have a list primed for a run at success, but it’s all about Port Adelaide’s mental strength.

When will West Coast’s experienced group regather themselves?

The Eagles’ start to the 2020 season has been the biggest shock. Boasting a midfield of Andrew Gaff, Elliot Yeo, Luke Shuey, Dom Sheed and Tim Kelly, they have no excuses for putting up such disappointing efforts. Josh Kennedy and Jack Darling have been listless up forward, while Shannon Hurn and his defensive group are showing signs of frailty.

Nic Naitanui has been a lone ranger in pushing his side forward, but he needs help. The onus is on Adam Simpson’s established side to find their form – are they able to do it, or are they too far down the rabbit hole?

It’s been a while since the Eagles have been able to sing the song (Daniel Carson/ Getty Images)

Tip: Honestly, who knows. I went for West Coast last week and was left bitterly disappointed. Port Adelaide aren’t reliable yet, but they may just get over the line here unless the Eagles bounce back extraordinarily quickly. Power by 10.

St Kilda v Richmond

Saturday 4.35PM

Marvel Stadium

Another nailbiter is ahead of us.

St Kilda are looking to prove that their stumbling loss to Collingwood last week was a slight setback in their progression. Back on their preferred track at Marvel Stadium, they have a real chance at upsetting the failing Tigers.

Much like the Eagles, Richmond need a win very soon if they are to right the ship.

Will we see Dusty back?

Dustin Martin’s rib soreness saw him sit out last week’s humbling loss to the Hawks. His impact was sorely missed in the middle, as his teammates couldn’t cover his absence. Dusty, regardless of his form, is a necessity for the yellow and black in these times. Just his presence may inspire his side into playing better.

Trent Cotchin needs to lead from the front (Michael Klein)

Similar to West Coast, the Tigers need their older heads to prevail if they are to blunt the Saints run. Dusty is the prime one to do it, but is he fully fit?

Is Billings and co ready to usurp the Tigers?

He may have had a quiet game against the Pies last week, but Jack Billings is ready to become an elite midfielder. With Jade Gresham also putting in consistent efforts in the middle, the younger St Kilda midfielders have a prime chance to out-run the Tigers and make a statement.

Ex-Tiger Dan Butler has been in great touch up forward, while Max King is already showing signs of becoming a powerhouse marking target. If St Kilda can win the centre battle, it’ll go a long way to breaking through Richmond. Their forward line will have to play much better than last week, but a functioning midfield may make their attack look so much more dangerous.

Tip: I’m always hesitant to go against Richmond, but this season has been full of upsets. I’m prepared to lose a tip here in going St Kilda by 19.

St Kilda’s on-ballers are the key on Saturday

Gold Coast v Fremantle

Saturday 7.40PM

Metricon Stadium

So much hype is surrounding Gold Coast and Matt Rowell. He has jumped out of the box to lead his young side to a commanding position at the end of Round 3. The big question is whether the Suns can continue this form against a miserly Freo.

Will Freo get consistent contributors?

To become a better side, Justin Longmuir needs more purple-clad men to give more. Nat Fyfe and Michael Walters have carried the load in 2020, but they need their forward line to click into gear and fire. If ex-Demon Jesse Hogan and Brandon Matera can find their feet, then Fyfe and Walters can spend more time controlling the midfield. It makes their team more balanced and dangerous. But if the Freo attackers continue to struggle, Fyfe will be left to shoulder all responsibility up forward.

Will someone help Michael Walters out, please? (Paul Kane/ Getty Images)

Can Witts keep his form going?

Underneath all the talk surrounding Gold Coast’s young guns, co-captain Jarrod Witts has started out terrifically. Rucking for the majority of games, he has beaten the likes of Nic Naitanui and Reilly O’Brien in recent weeks. He has always been an impressive tap ruckman, but he is now starting to develop his around the ground craft.

Sean Darcy and Rory Lobb are both good ruckmen on their day. But they have been scratchy; Witts looks set to claim another ruck win, and it could go a long way to winning his side the match.

The Suns have rebounded off the back of savvy recruiting and smart draft picks (Darren England/ AAP)

Tip: It’s hard not to ignore the Suns’ talk. Freo are tricky, but Gold Coast have too much firepower across the board. Suns by 30.

Essendon v Carlton

Saturday 7.40PM

MCG

Despite last week’s COVID-scare, the Bombers should be fit and ready to go on Saturday night. It’s still hard to get a read on Essendon after their scrappy start to 2020, while Carlton’s season was given a major boost when beating the Cats last week. The famous rivalry will heat back up in unfamiliar circumstances at the ‘G.

How will everything impact the Bombers?

Essendon have had a crazy few weeks.

Andrew McGrath is in good form (Dylan Burns/ Getty Images)

After overcoming the Swans in an underwhelming performance, captain Dyson Heppell broke his foot and Conor McKenna sent a ripple of fear over the competition. Everything now looks better for the Dons, who will not lose many players to quarantine. The main issue will be the COVID-induced bye – will they be able to find their feet quickly in this game? They need to, for Carlton aren’t the easy opponents they used to be.

Was Eddie’s effort a flash in the pan?

Last Saturday night Carlton’s forward line changed remarkably. Jack Martin continued his dominance across half-forward, while Mitch McGovern and Levi Casboult marked everything. If they let one slip, Eddie Betts was everywhere. It’s been years since Carlton’s forward six were that dangerous.

The task is to replicate this. They have an easier assignment than the Cats at GMHBA Stadium, but complacency is a horrible thing in football. All eyes will be on this forward line – with Patrick Cripps in better touch, they’ll get the service required to win the game. It’s all about whether they’ll take their chance.

Tip: Another ridiculously hard one to read. Essendon are the great unknown, and I’m too scared to hedge my bets on them. They’ll warm into a good side, and Carlton may not be able to back up after such an inspiring win. Lineball on this one – Dons by 7.

Carlton’s fortunes lie with Patrick Cripps

Brisbane v Adelaide

Sunday 1.05PM

The Gabba

In a round of tight tussles, this is one of the only matches with a clear favourite. Adelaide are a rabble, and can’t be expected to suddenly bounce back. Stranger things have happened, but if Brisbane are the real deal then they must win easily.

When will Brisbane’s forward line fire?

Many Brisbane eyes will be on Eric Hipwood. He is only showing frustrating glimpses of his potential. For someone who has the ability to win games off his own boot, he must perform to keep his side’s winning streak going.

Young players in Jarrod Berry, Hugh McCluggage and Alex Witherden are all improving rapidly. Hipwood is the last piece of the puzzle – if he is improving then the Lions can win games when not playing at their best.

Brisbane’s young leaders are aiming for finals again (Sporting News)

Give Doedee some help

Since returning from his ACL injury in 2019, Tom Doedee has gone under the radar. In a defence that has been bombarded like no other, he has held his own and continued to dominate down back. But he needs some assistance.

Doedee already has his hands full with the best tall forwards in the league. Now, Rory Laird, Jake Kelly and Luke Brown need to give him some help so he can continue progressing his intercept game.

The Crows need to be together on Sunday if they are to have any chance (ACFC)

Tip: Adelaide may give more of a yelp, but Brisbane simply must win. Lions by 47.

Melbourne v Geelong

Sunday 3.35PM

MCG

Melbourne are another side who are unknown. Their tight win against the Blues was made to look better when Carlton snatched victory over the Cats. With their match against Essendon being postponed, they have had an extra week to work on their game.

After a break, Melbourne will be looking to avoid this feeling (Richard Wainwright/ AAP)

The Dees forwards will be tested

Melbourne’s small and versatile forward group managed to just get the win over Carlton two weeks ago. Christian Petracca and Jayden Hunt were electric and fast, but the likes of Tom Stewart, Mark Blicavs and Zach Tuohy will make life much harder.

Young Luke Jackson has an impossible task ahead of him against this defence. Tom McDonald must contribute with some goals, while Alex Neal-Bullen and his other small forwards need to get the ball to ground and run rings around Geelong to post a winning total.

Who will go with Max Gawn?

The one player capable of turning the game is Max Gawn. He did it in the latter stages against Carlton, and is primed to do so again here. Rhys Stanley’s Round 3 was a let-down – he now has one of the toughest jobs in the league against the Dees captain.

Gawn will give his midfield a decisive advantage at stoppages, so it’s a head-scratcher to see how Geelong can stop him. The Cats centremen must be dynamic in sharking his taps if they have any chance of winning clearances.

Tip: Melbourne could easily get up here, but Geelong will be looking to bounce back hard after last week’s let-down. The Dees have what it takes – it’s a flip of the coin. Cats by 5. I could be wrong though.

Geelong’s big three must be at their best on Sunday (The Australian)

Hawthorn v North Melbourne

Sunday 6.10PM

Marvel Stadium

Of course, this difficult round must end on another hard one.

Hawthorn were a completely different side in Round 3 to the one that lost to Geelong. With Jaeger O’Meara back controlling the midfield, the Hawks blitzed the Tigers. North Melbourne were left seething after giving up a win against the Swans. Who will come up trumps on Sunday?

Which midfield will triumph?

Ben Cunnington should be back for the Roos, meaning their midfield will return to full strength. Todd Goldstein against Jonathon Ceglar and Ben McEvoy will be an intriguing battle. The tough blue and white bulls in Jy Simpkin, Jed Anderson and Shaun Higgins will have a tight fight against O’Meara, Tom Mitchell and James Worpel.

Hawk Tom Mitchell has a big role to play (Michael Dodge/ AAP)

This is a tantalising match-up – both midfields are on the rise and are capable of beating anyone. The team who is more focused and intense at the footy will win this one.

Now is the time for Ben Brown

After a slow start, Ben Brown is starting to find his touch. A handful of goals last week brought him into the game, yet he drifted out of the latter stages when the match was on the line. In a 50/50 game, Brown needs a consistent display of marking to stamp his presence on the contest. If not, Hawthorn have the rebounding defenders to make the Roos pay.

Star forward Ben Brown has a massive chance to kick start his season on Sunday (Getty Images)

Tip: With all the emotion surrounding Hawthorn this weekend, they may just be fired up enough to get the win. Hawks by 12.

AFL 2020 Round 3 Review (so far) – Port and Collingwood motor on despite COVID-19 fears

Of course, we could never get the footy fully back to normal, could we?

Thursday and Friday night upsets meant the AFL finally felt back in its usual swing. Everything was slowly getting better. Then the league was thrown back up in the air. With all matches except the Essendon and Melbourne clash being played, let’s take a look back at what we can.

Richmond 5.9 (39) defeated by Hawthorn 11.5 (71)

Hawthorn’s Tom Scully gets a kick away during his side’s upset win over the Tigers (AAP: Michael Dodge)

Despite missing Dustin Martin, Richmond were still expected to get the job done against the Hawks. But Alastair Clarkson’s men came to the MCG to play, and they pulled outa measured and unbreakable brand of smart footy that proved Clarkson’s ability to thwart even the greatest of modern sides.

Jaeger O’Meara is crucially important to the Hawthorn engine room

Last Friday night the brown and gold were trounced by a Geelong midfield complimented by a blend of young and old. Without ex-Sun O’Meara, Hawthorn’s centre brigade lacked pace and were cleaned up. Fast forward six days and O’Meara’s return sparked a turnaround in the midfield. Getting 16 disposals (and using them at 100% efficiency) in the first half was the catalyst to the Hawks fast start, which saw them slam on five goals to nothing in the first term. He finished with 23 touches and a goal to highlight just how dangerous he can be when slotting in beside ball magnet Tom Mitchell and the exciting James Worpel.

The inclusion of O’Meara also freed up Chad Wingard, who constantly thwarted Richmond across the half-forward line.

Ex-Port star Chad Wingard is settling into a rhythm at Hawthorn (Robert Cianflone/ Getty Images)

What can Richmond do to revive Riewoldt?

It was the second week in a row that the trusty Jack Riewoldt produced nothing.

Last week’s horror show could be written off as an aberration, but Thursday night’s meagre 11 disposals and two behinds now confirms he is out of form. With the Tigers slipping, the pressure put on Tom Lynch up forward is too much. With the likes of Shai Bolton, Daniel Rioli and Marlion Pickett also underperforming, Riewoldt needs to quickly find his feet if Richmond are to get back on track.

Verdict: Hawthorn are back and hunting for a finals spot, while Richmond have some work to do if they are to regain their footing in the top four.

Richmond need to acclimatise to the lack of crowd (AFL Photos/ Getty Images)

Western Bulldogs 8.9 (57) defeated GWS 4.9 (33)

If Thursday night’s upset was seismic, this Friday boilover was just as impactful. GWS had to bounce back and prove their insipid effort against the Roos was a rare mistake. Instead, they stumbled further over their own feet and plummeted down the ladder. The Dogs rediscovered their fire, fighting hard for the win in a tense clash which featured ill blood and little niggles throughout the contest.

The return of Libba makes the Bulldogs’ midfield a lot better

After another lay-off, the AFL world got a taste of just how crucial Tom Liberatore is to the Bulldogs’ bash-and-crash style of footy. Libba had 18 touches and four clearances, yet his impact was not anywhere near statistical. There was a changed air around the ball whenever he charged in. With the no-frills Bulldog out-working GWS to win the contested possessions, his teammates lifted with him. Marcus Bontempelli overcame some physical targeting to kick the sealer via a miracle goal from the ground. Jack Macrae and Caleb Daniel both returned to their dynamic best, while Bailey Smith’s is continuing to thrive in his new role as a midfielder.

Bulldogs captain Marcus Bontempelli celebrates a wonderful last quarter goal (Western Bulldogs FC)

To sum up Libba’s fine night, his calm set shot after the three-quarter time siren when melees were breaking out around him says wonders about his ability. With Libba back in, there are echoes of the Bulldogs’ 2016 attack on the footy.

Once again, the Giants mistake attack the man for attacking the footy

Giants and Bulldogs players clash in a wild melee (AAP: Scott Barbour)

This isn’t the first time Leon Cameron has tried to instil an edge of aggression on his players. He has all the talent in the world at his disposal, yet he can’t quite seem to encourage his side to consistently attack the ball.

GWS clearly don’t like the Bulldogs, and they came out trying to hurt their opponents. It began with the weird decision to throw Nick Haynes up to do the coin toss with Bontempelli in an attempt to throw off the Bulldogs captain after an incident late last year. Then, the Giants almost forgot the game was underway, for they only had eyes on the Bont. This haphazard approach only gave away free kicks and goals. When it came to the actual footy, they turned a blind eye.

Verdict: The Dogs had to work hard for this, but now they know what it takes to win a tough game of footy. GWS need to quickly change their mindset to just winning the ball, for their futile attempts at aggression could backfire spectacularly against the Magpies.

Phil Davis and his Giants need to respond in Round 4 (Matt King/Getty Images)

North Melbourne 8.12 (60) defeated by Sydney 10.11 (71)

The Kangaroos, following a stunning upset against the Giants, were meant to consolidate with a third successive strong win. But for all of their effort in last week’s impressive win, they dropped the bundle on Saturday. Sydney were furious after giving up four points to Essendon the previous Sunday, and made sure they were leaving Marvel Stadium with a victory this time.

Sydney’s cobbled together forward line did the job terrifically

Without Buddy Franklin and Sam Reid, the Swans have no reliable tall forward option to use. Last week, Nick Blakey and Tom McCartin were out played by Essendon’s big defenders. This week, they were barely required – a wave of dangerous mid-sized forwards did all the damage.

Isaac Heeney was a constant threat both up forward and in the guts with his 18 disposal and one goal game. He was everywhere, and was constantly setting up the likes of Tom Papley and Will Hayward. The Sydney pair gave North Melbourne defenders plenty of headaches.

Sydney’s Nick Blakey (right) celebrates a crucial goal (AFL Photos)

Sydney found the key to posting a winning score, and it was through their midfield. Their spread of goalkickers was far and wide, with veteran on-ballers Luke Parker and Josh Kennedy leading their young troops with majors from the midfield. If they continue to play with such zip and pace, they will have the weapons available to score heavily.

No Cunnington throws out North Melbourne’s midfield balance

Last week GWS tagger Matt de Boer went to Cunnington in an effort to stem his brutal contested ball work. The Giant succeeded, but Shaun Higgins stepped up instead. Without Cunnington, Sydney blanketed the dynamic influence of Higgins and were able to out-work North Melbourne’s other midfielders.

Ben Cunnington’s (right) presence is sorely needed for North Melbourne

Although Jy Simpkin is having a breakout year, he can’t be expected to shoulder the entire midfield when Higgins is struggling. Jed Anderson was relatively quiet, while Todd Goldstein fought hard but made some poor decisions early on in the match. The Roos need Cunnington demanding attention in the midfield, or else they will be dominated by more experienced centremen in the coming rounds.

Verdict: Sydney are flying under the radar perfectly, while North Melbourne received a harsh reality check.

Collingwood 12.9 (81) defeated St Kilda 5.7 (37)

The Pies came out in sparkling touch to dismiss any notion they were as rusty as the Tigers, Eagles and Giants. A late six goal burst before half time followed a five goal first quarter to establish a rampant buffer that they were never going to relinquish. St Kilda fought hard in patches, but were given a lesson in how leading teams need to consistently play.

Rowan Marshall (left) lost his ruck battle with Collingwood’s Brodie Grundy (right) (The Australian)

The return of Stephenson changes Collingwood’s forward line drastically

In the second half of last week’s draw, the Magpies looked stagnant and were never a realistic shot of kicking a goal. It was obvious Nathan Buckley had thought about this issue – in the first quarter alone the Collingwood forward line was bursting with pace and dripping with talent. Jaidyn Stephenson’s inclusion played a big part in this revamp – he booted the Pies’ first two goals through searching leads and an eye-catching ability to create a chance out of nothing.

His presence also freed up Jamie Elliott from heavy attention, meaning he could get off the leash to snag an early brace of goals. Brody Mihocek was another to benefit, as the forward line looked a lot more open and free flowing with Stephenson constantly creating space. With the black and white back line currently in red hot form, the forward group is the key to their success in 2020. And Stephenson may just be the last piece of the puzzle.

Steele Sidebottom was at his silky best on Saturday (AAP)

Dan Butler’s shining performance brushes over the midfield’s cracks

Richmond would be crying out for Butler right now. With their own small forwards failing to get near the footy, the new Saint put in another wonderful game on Saturday. Two goals and a flurry of creative touches meant he was constantly involved in any St Kilda forays forward, no matter how rare they were.

But despite this positive, the Saints midfield went from hero to zero very quickly. Jack Billings’ couldn’t get close to recreating his game-winning round two heights; Seb Ross, Jack Steele and Zak Jones were also callously shut down by the experienced hands of Pendlebury, Sidebottom and Adams. To add salt to the wound, St Kilda’s twin rucks in Paddy Ryder and Rowan Marshall failed to reel in Brodie Grundy – the Magpie big man ended up winning the hit-out battle against both of them after a slow start.

Verdict: Collingwood separate themselves as one of the two best sides in the competition at the moment. St Kilda are tracking well, but they can’t get too far ahead of themselves yet.

Paddy Ryder gets a hurried kick away (Getty Images)

Brisbane 10.14 (74) defeated West Coast 6.8 (44)

The Lions proved their ability on Saturday night with a tough and ugly win over flag fancy West Coast. Losing skipper Dayne Zorko before the bounce didn’t help, but they managed to put in a consistent performance to shoot into the top eight. The Eagles are in a spot of bother – stuck in Queensland and horribly out of touch, they face real strife if they don’t rediscover their brilliant best form.

The Berry brothers are crucial to Brisbane’s future

Tom Berry had already made his mark on the AFL in just his first game with a courageous mark in the dying stages of his side’s triumph over Fremantle last week. His attack on the footy shone through again in his second match, as he seemed to pop up in key moments to beat hardened West Coast bodies to the ball.

Brisbane younger players were impressive on Saturday night (The Weekly Times)

His older brother Jarrod Berry became a handful in the middle, winning the ball and setting up many forward thrusts during the home side’s third quarter blitz. With Lachie Neale (32 touches and two goals) continuing his hot start to 2020, Berry managed to slot three crucial majors to guide Brisbane home.

Nic Nat is only just warming up

Other than Andrew Gaff, West Coast’s midfield is underperforming. Dom Sheed can’t get his hands on the ball, while new skipper Luke Shuey isn’t living up to his usual standards. Luckily, Nic Naitanui put in a wonderful performance in the ruck on Saturday night.

Throughout most of the encounter he was the sole force keeping the Eagles in the contest. He was best on ground at the main break and continued to try his best when the Lions pulled away. Adam Simpson has a lot to worry about during the week, but Nic Nat isn’t one. Fingers crossed he stays fit, for he is a sight to behold when in full flight.

Verdict: Brisbane are steadily improving week-by-week. West Coast need a boost soon before their season falls away.

West Coast need to improve quickly up in Queensland (Brisbane News)

Geelong 11.11 (77) defeated by Carlton 12.7 (79)

This was a tale of two halves.

Carlton, playing down at the imposing GHMBA Stadium fortress, got off to a flyer. Patrick Cripps was electric in the middle. Eddie Betts couldn’t be stopped. Mitch McGovern and Levi Casboult finally became aerial threats. The Cats had no way of stemming the flow, and were in dire straits heading into the final term.

Tom Hawkins and Jacob Weitering tussle for the ball (AFL)

But the seasoned Geelong crew managed to pull their side back into it. If it wasn’t for some strange decisions by certain Cats then they may have stolen victory. But it wasn’t to be, as Eddie Betts secured the important victory with a desperate final minute tackle.

Was Alastair Clarkson right last week?

Despite getting smacked by Geelong in last Friday night’s game, the Hawthorn coach believed that the Cats weren’t that good. With only one win after three games, the master coach may have been spot on.

Rhys Stanley’s round two performance looked a lifetime ago due to a sloppy effort on Saturday night. Without Brandon Parfitt, the younger Geelong midfielders did nothing to help the experienced hands. Tom Hawkins and Esava Ratugolea were once again quiet, with the latter double-fisting a straight shot on goal by Hawkins that may well have sailed through. Gryan Miers was busy up forward but made some wrong decisions with the game on the line. If their win over Hawthorn was free flowing, their round three performance was shaky and tentative.

Esava Ratugolea needs to lift for the Cats (The Advertiser)

Carlton’s recruits hold the key to their season

When Carlton snared Mitch McGovern and Eddie Betts from Adelaide while grabbing Jack Martin from up north, the AFL world was unsure as to how it would all come together. It took until Saturday night for the trio to show their potential.

Betts was on fire from the first bounce, and belied his age to constantly threaten Geelong’s seasoned small defenders. McGovern began to clunk big marks and show he has the ability to rediscover his valuable touch. Martin has already proven to be one of the Blues best – he is the link man between midfield and half-forward, and has an impressive ability to create whenever he has the Sherrin in his hands.

Verdict: Geelong need to prove they aren’t flat-track bullies, but Carlton have a new lease of life… just.

Harry McKay tries to bust out of a Geelong stranglehold (The Guardian)

Gold Coast 12.10 (82) defeated Adelaide 4.5 (29)

If Gold Coast fans thought it couldn’t get any better after downing the Eagles last week, they were in for a pleasant surprise. The Suns were no one-hit wonders, and promptly went on to smack Adelaide and demote them to wooden spoon favouritism. Not since Gary Ablett Jnr’s arrival on the Gold Coast has a player demanded so much attention, but now young Matt Rowell is the talk of the town after backing up his player of the match effort last week with another influential effort.

Gold Coast are sparking some interest across the country (The Chronicle)

Gold Coast’s youngsters may just be the real deal

In the coming weeks the name Matt Rowell will be bandied about on every AFL related show, and fair enough. It’s a struggle to name another first year player who has come in and performed so well right from the get-go. But it’s not just Rowell who has breathed life into the failing Suns.

Noah Anderson has been quietly excelling. For large parts of Sunday’s game he matched up on star Crow Rory Sloane – the youngster held his own, and in some plays managed to beat Adelaide’s skipper in the contest. Jack Bowes impressed with his 20 touches, while Ben King is starting to become a handful up forward. Under the guidance of veteran Sam Day, King was the best tall forward on the ground with his three majors. Also deserving of a mention are Wil Powell and Connor Budarick; the entire improvement of this young group is what makes Gold Coast an exciting and intimidating prospect.

Gold Coast’s experienced players are starting to thrive off some younger additions (Sarah Reed/ News Corp Australia)

Adelaide have a long, long season ahead

The 2020 season may be shortened due to the COVID-19 pandemic, but that doesn’t mean it won’t drag out for the Crows. They are the only winless team in the league, and are confined to a horror year.

The issue is stemming from their leaders. Many players have vacated the Crows over the past few seasons, but Rory Sloane still remains. He could only gather 15 touches, the Crouch brothers just passed 20 possessions each. Taylor Walker is a shadow of his former self. Tom Doedee is being left without help in the back line. You can point fingers all you want at the younger players who don’t look up to the standard of AFL, but the main reason why that is happening is because they are receiving no help or guidance from experienced players who should be better. Until they start to pull their share, Adelaide will be stuck in the mud.

Adelaide’s Brad Crouch needs to lift if his side are to avoid a nightmare season (Scott Barbour/ Getty Images)

Verdict: The Suns are hot, and could be building a case for a debut finals series. Adelaide, after three rounds, are already in rebuild mode.

Fremantle 6.5 (41) defeated by Port Adelaide 10.10 (70)

In what started as a high-scoring encounter, Port Adelaide scrapped their way to a third straight impressive win. Unlike the first two victories, the Power didn’t have it all their way, but they proved too strong in the decisive moments. Fremantle were again left relying on Nat Fyfe and Michael Walters; they didn’t have enough depth to challenge Port Adelaide deep into the second half.

Fyfe and Walters – you need four of them

Nothing proves the God-like status of Fyfe then a few minutes in the last quarter. After working hard all night against a seasoned Port Adelaide midfield, Freo coach Justin Longmuir flung Fyfe forward in an attempt to generate some score on the board. The issue was that the ball barely came down there. When it did, Fyfe flew to bring in two towering marks – the skipper was so exhausted by his Herculean efforts that he could only convert one of the set shots.

Michael Walters faced a similar prospect – he wasn’t as clean as usual, but he still couldn’t stop getting the footy. When either he or Fyfe won the ball and sent it forward, there was no target to go to. James Aish once again lent a helping hand, but they need more from Adam Cerra and Andrew Brayshaw. Jesse Hogan looks the best option for a tall forward target, but needs time to adjust to footy.  

Darcy Tucker (left) is harassed by Hamish Hartlett (right) in his side’s loss up on the Gold Coast (Perth Now)

Port Adelaide’s depth is the best in the competition

The Power have relied on their emerging crop of young talent to comfortably win the first two rounds. But a blend of youth and experience banded together on Sunday night to pull away from the Dockers.

Charlie Dixon is in ominous form up forward – he is marking everything, and he’s making a great combination with Justin Westhoff and Todd Marshall. Ollie Wines came back in for his first game of the season, and dominated in the guts with Travis Boak and Tom Rockliff.

Although Xavier Duursma looks to have fallen to a serious hamstring injury, the Power still have Connor Rozee, Sam Powell-Pepper and Robbie Gray to pick up the slack. If Gray can get away with having a quiet start to the season, then Port Adelaide are a side to be feared.

Charlie Dixon (centre) is becoming one of the leading tall forwards in the game (Chris Hyde/ Getty Images)

Verdict: Fremantle are yearning for some development from their young midfielders. Port Adelaide are becoming more of a flag chance the longer they remain undefeated.

Rating: 1 out of 5.

AFL 2020 Round 3 Preview: Settling into a rhythm

The cobwebs have blown away. Now, it’s time to settle into the season.

It was wonderful to have AFL action back last weekend. Starting off slow and a little boring, the round kicked into gear throughout the weekend. We got some thrilling results and major upsets. Now, what can Round 3 provide?

Hawthorn’s Paul Puopolo and Tiger Dylan Grimes will once again renew acquaintances on Thursday night footy (SEN)

Richmond v Hawthorn

Thursday 7.40PM

MCG

It’s rare that Dustin Martin is out injured.

After a sub-par return to footy last Thursday in his side’s draw against Collingwood, he is now sitting out due to rib soreness. His experienced teammates will need to pick up the slack if the Tigers are to return to the winners’ list.

Hawthorn had a shocking second half last Friday night down at the Cattery, and must respond quickly if they are to save the sinking ship. The return of Jaeger O’Meara is a great start, but they’re going to need to play a blinder if they are to knock off the reigning premiers.

How good are Richmond this year?

It’s been incredibly tough to get a good read on Richmond so far in season 2020. Their opening round win over Carlton started off beautifully, but their second half turned the victory into an unconvincing four goal triumph.

To reverse their fortunes, the Tigers barely gave a yelp when Collingwood started off hard and fast in Round 2. However, their third and fourth quarters were full of grit and the thrilling bash-and-crash play we are used to from the yellow and black.

Now, it’s time Damian Hardwick’s men step up to the plate and show they are still one of the best teams in the competition.

Dustin Martin, seen here taking a mark in 2017, won’t be coming up against the Hawks tonight (SEN)

Can Hawthorn fix their dysfunctional forward line?

To give the Hawks credit, they somehow managed to stay in the game during last week’s first half. Geelong looked the better team by a long way, yet it took until the third quarter for the Cats to streak away with the win.

In the first half, Jack Gunston was efficient in front of goal, papering over the cracks that occur when Jon Patton struggles to take big marks and Luke Breust is tagged out of the game. The Hawthorn forward line is ageing – Round 3 is one of the last chances the likes of Breust and Paul Puopolo might get before they are replaced by some younger blood. For their sake, they need to chip in with bags of goals to post a competitive total.

Tip: Richmond without Dusty is always a less potent force, but they still have the star quality to get the job done tonight. Tigers by 37.

Brownlow Medallist Tom Mitchell will finally get to play Richmond again (AAP: Julian Smith)

Western Bulldogs v GWS

Friday 7.50PM

Marvel Stadium

If ever the Dogs are to make a statement and arrest their worrying slump, it will come against the Giants. The two sides have forged a unique rivalry since the 2016 Preliminary Final. Now, both teams have points to prove.

The Bulldogs have started off the season horrendously. Their recruits have failed to fire, while their midfield is worryingly slow. A win here would avoid lots of scrutiny. On the other hand, GWS were pathetic against North Melbourne for large stages of their Round 2 match. They were out grunted around the ball and couldn’t find any space. To prove they are still a flag fancy, they must get the win over the unconfident Bulldogs.

The Bulldogs celebrate their 2016 triumph which kick-started a modern-day rivalry (Getty Images: Ryan Pierse)

What to do with Bailey Smith and Jackson Macrae?

Before their Round 2 loss to the Saints, coach Luke Beveridge mixed things up. Jack Macrae was thrown onto a wing and sometimes up forward, while young forward Bailey Smith was chucked onto the ball. Smith responded with one of his best games for the club in his short career, but Macrae was horribly out of sorts.

Coming up against a tough and well-drilled Tigers midfield, what will Beveridge do now? It’s a very hard choice to move Smith out of the middle when he performed so well on Sunday. The onus lies on Macrae, who must make himself dangerous on a wing or up forward to make the tactical move work.

Can Jeremy Cameron find a spark?

Last year’s Brownlow Medallist Jeremy Cameron doesn’t look right. His Round 1 effort before the extended break was up to his usual standard – three goals in a five-goal win was exactly what we are used to. But against the Kangaroos, Cameron was destroyed by Robbie Tarrant. He only registered a single goal out of his meagre seven disposals.

Jeremy Finlayson and Harry Himmelberg are more than capable of having a day out, but GWS play at their best when Cameron is up and going. In a must-win clash, they need their star forward to kick a bag to make sure they get over the line.

Sparks set to fly when the Bulldogs and Giants clash on Friday night footy (SEN)

Tip: Both teams will show plenty of fire after poor losses last week, but the Giants are too clean on the outside. They should get home comfortably. GWS by 40.

North Melbourne v Sydney

Saturday 1.45PM

Marvel Stadium

This fixture is a lot more intriguing than what it promised to be after Round 1.

Star forward Ben Brown is looking to have a massive night out against the Swans (Michael Dodge/ Getty Images)

North Melbourne, following a stunning win against the Giants, sit undefeated, while the Swans were only a goal or two away from being in the same situation. The Kangaroos look rejuvenated under Rhyce Shaw, playing a fast and brutal brand of attacking footy fuelled by young stars. The Swans are full of youthful faces who are capable of stepping up to help the likes of Josh Kennedy and Luke Parker – can they do it against the Roos?

Are North Melbourne now the toughest team to face?

There’s an argument to be made that the Roos are now the side all others hate to face most. They play such a tough brand of footy that all opponents are guaranteed to limp off the ground with plenty of bruises after coming up against them. Led by the bullish Ben Cunnington and the enforcing hard bodies of Jed Anderson and Cameron Zurhaar, the Shinboners are living up to their namesake.

Their success is clearly related to their fierce intent to go hard at the ball and win all contested situations. The next step is to make this a week in, week out occurrence that would cement their spot as the toughest team in the AFL.

Will Isaac Heeney and Tom Papley step up?

Both Heeney and Papley promise so much for the Swans. They have been wonderful forwards for numerous years. Now, they are starting to transition into the midfield.

The Sydney pair drip with X-factor, and are more than capable of kicking a bag of goals while racking up plenty of decisive touches in the middle. The red and white are yearning for this versatility – if the Swans are to break open the tight shell of the Kangaroos, they need their dynamic talents to produce something special.

Can Luke Parker guide his younger teammates to victory? (Getty Images)

Tip: Sydney should be an annoying team to face, but their young bodies aren’t yet ready to match it with North Melbourne. Kennedy and Parker will provide some resilience, but the Kangaroos should grind their way home to a third successive win. Roos by 24.

Collingwood v St Kilda

Saturday 4.40PM

MCG

Halfway through Thursday night’s match, most pundits would have been ready to place money on Collingwood. Following the eventual draw, and St Kilda’s wonderful free-flowing performance on Sunday, the odds are now much tighter.

The main battle will be between Brodie Grundy and the twin tower combo of Paddy Ryder and Rowan Marshall, who destroyed the Bulldogs. Ryder and Marshall are eerily similar to the Scott Lycett/ Nathan Vardy duo that bested Grundy in the 2018 Grand Final. Both sides have quick midfields, but it’ll come down to has the most poise and potency down forward.

Is 2020 St Kilda’s year to make a finals charge? (St Kilda FC)

Will experience or youth prevail in the middle?

St Kilda’s on-ball brigade looked the best it has in a long time on Sunday. With Jack Billings starring, Jack Steele, Jade Gresham, Seb Ross and Hunter Clark all thrived in the guts. Chuck in the experienced Dan Hannebery and the red, white and black have plenty of flexibility in the midfield, especially with Zak Jones and Brad Hill running rampant on the wing.

But they will face a much sterner test in the wise heads of Scott Pendlebury and Steele Sidebottom. Alongside the impressive Taylor Adams, Jordan De Goey and the up-and-coming Tyler Brown, the Saints won’t get anywhere near as much room to roam this Saturday. It’ll be an intriguing test to see whether St Kilda will prove too quick for the Pies or if the old black and white firm will use their nous to win the midfield battle.

Is St Kilda’s forward line good enough to crack Collingwood’s defence?

For all of Collingwood’s versatility and breathtaking ability up forward, it’s their back line that performs the best. Jeremy Howe was in scintillating form last week, and could be used once more as a spare man behind the ball to thwart all St Kilda attacks. Darcy Moore and Jordan Roughead will give Max King and Tim Membrey hell, so the Saints will have to be creative going forward.

Since the latter stages of last year, Collingwood’s defence has been impressively tight. The key match-up will be between Dan Butler and Brayden Maynard. If the talls don’t flourish, the Saints need their snappy crumbers to get the job done.

Collingwood’s experienced group managed to beat the Saints in 2019 – can they repeat the dose in Round 3? (Getty Images)

Will Collingwood change their forward line?

The Magpies failed to kick a goal in the entire second half of last week’s game. When they are forced into a slow down the line match, they struggle to score. The likes of Josh Thomas and Will Hoskin-Elliott were unsighted last Thursday – will one of them make way for Jaidyn Stephenson?

Tip: This will be very close. St Kilda are dangerous. The Pies should still get over the line – just. Magpies by 12.

Brisbane v West Coast

Saturday 7.40PM

The Gabba

Brisbane will be looking to hand West Coast a second straight defeat on Saturday night (Chris Hyde/ Getty Images)

After last week’s results, this match is now hard to pick. West Coast, following a horror loss to the Suns, need to clean up their act quickly.

Brisbane held firm to squeak out a win against Fremantle – can they back it up to make it two on the trot?

Will West Coast’s midfield rebound?

The likes of Luke Shuey, Andrew Gaff, Elliot Yeo and Tim Kelly had their pants pulled down by young Matt Rowell and co last Saturday night. For such a wonderful assortment of players, they were shamed by the league’s supposed worst team. We now know Gold Coast are improving, but West Coast have to show Round 2 was an aberration.

Alongside these midfielders, Nic Naitanui has a key role in rejuvenating the engine room. He needs to become more dangerous around the ground to exploit Brisbane’s weakness in the ruck.

Can Eric Hipwood capitalise on Jeremy McGovern’s absence?

Hipwood had an interesting game in Round 2. He had a horror first half, but kick-started the Lions in the third term with an early goal. Hipwood has the potential to be a star, but he needs to start developing. He won’t get a better chance than facing West Coast without Jeremy McGovern, who’s tribunal appeal was thrown out.

Hipwood will most likely line up on Tom Barrass, who is lacking confidence and could be vulnerable when isolated. If the lanky Lion wants to kick a bag, this weekend is his time.

The Brisbane engine room, led by Dayne Zorko, are looking towards the top eight once more (AAP)

Tip: Brisbane looked good, and Lachie Neale and Charlie Cameron will be hard to stop. But West Coast are a quality side, and quality sides manage to win in these scenarios. Eagles by 17.

Geelong v Carlton

Saturday 7.40PM

GMHBA Stadium

The Cats will rock up to their home ground brimming with confidence after dismantling Hawthorn last Friday in a terrific win. Lots of heart will be taken out of the performances by Rhys Stanley and Brandon Parfitt, who were integral to the big victory.

Carlton lost a game they should have won – their shocking first half gave way to a fast-running last quarter that gave them many chances to grab the four points. They now face a tough trip where they’ll have to be a lot more consistent to snag a victory.

Will Rhys Stanley back up his Friday night special?

The Cats are crying out for a ruckman to snatch their spot in the team. Often a weakness since the departure of club hero Brad Ottens, Geelong fans sat back in satisfaction last Friday when Rhys Stanley kicked two goals in a match-winning performance.

He will line up in the ruck ahead of Darcy Fort again on Saturday night. Now, he must back up his Round 2 effort by overcoming a tricky opponent in Carlton’s Marc Pittonet. If he can have another industrious tonight, Geelong fans may start to believe they’ve solved their ruck problem.

Now without Tim Kelly (left), Geelong will have to work hard to overcome Sam Walsh (right) and his Blues (Herald Sun)

Will Cripps stand up?

Patrick Cripps has a lot of hype surrounding him. He is one of the favourites to take home a Brownlow Medal in the next few years, while his improving side have finals aspirations. In the last quarter of their Round 2 loss to Melbourne, Cripps had multiple set shot opportunities to give his Blues the lead with only minutes left. He couldn’t take them, only slotting one goal to bring them within a kick.

Cripps, now a leader at the club, must show his younger teammates the way. If the Blues are to show any sign of improvement, it must come from the top.

Tip: Geelong should be way too good here, regardless of which Carlton turns up to the Cattery. Cats by 38.

Patrick Cripps needs to lift for Carlton (Carlton FC)

Gold Coast v Adelaide

Sunday 1.05PM

Metricon Stadium

Before Round 2, this match would have been a meaningless game; a fight between two disappointing clubs to claim wooden spoon favouritism. But Matt Rowell’s Saturday night effort means many eyes will be watching to confirm whether he is the real deal.

Adelaide must find an avenue to goal, as another loss would be disastrous. Suddenly, this Sunday match-up has plenty of interesting storylines surrounding it.

Ex-Tiger Brandon Ellis could be a key player in Gold Coast’s clash with Adelaide (Getty Images)

How good can Gold Coast’s forward line be?

Last Saturday night, the AFL world got an inkling of how dangerous the Gold Coast Suns could be. Stuart Dew has put together a surprisingly talented forward line that gave West Coast’s experienced defenders headaches. With veteran Sam Day firing, Ben King and Alex Sexton were able to roam freely.

Will Day once again be influential? If so, the other young Suns should continue to hit the scoreboard regularly against a Crows defence lacking any organisation.

When will Tex lift?

Taylor Walker may not be captain anymore, but he has a massive responsibility. With Rory Sloane in doubt due to an injury concern, he will once again hold the reigns as the most senior leader.

His Showdown effort was poor – for young Darcy Fogarty to flourish, Walker must command the presence of the opposition’s best defender. The Crows need goals, and Tex is their key to a big night on the Gold Coast.

With Rory Sloane in doubt, the Crows need to find a spark (Daniel Kalisz/ Getty Images)

Tip: Gold Coast should repeat a similar effort to last week and hand the Crows another defeat. Suns by 28.

Essendon v Melbourne

Sunday 3.35PM

MCG

Both teams crawled over the line for wins. Essendon is the most unconvincing undefeated side going around, and will have to perform better than their stop-start Sunday win against Sydney. Melbourne completely stopped in the second half of their one-point victory over Carlton. They were lucky to come away with a win, but now have a chance to snatch a second straight triumph.

What value does Essendon’s older heads have?

Skipper Dyson Heppell and David Zaharakis were atrocious last Sunday. Neither got near the Sherrin, and when they did they looked way too slow. Both may be taking their time to acclimatise to the rigours of AFL footy, but they can’t keep taking key spots in the team if they contribute so little. With Darcy Parish and Andrew McGrath now expecting more midfield time, Heppell and Zaharakis must give justification for their selection by winding back the clock. The Bombers are hell-bent on finally clinching a post-season win, so they must be ruthless.

Will Dyson Heppell lift for his Bombers? (Daniel Pockett/ AFL Media/ Getty Images)

Who wins – Jayden Hunt or Adam Saad?

Two of the most dynamic and exciting players will most likely go head-to-head on Sunday. Jayden Hunt, after being in and out of the Melbourne side over the past couple of years, finally looked to be playing well. His three majors were the difference; now, he must replicate it while on Adam Saad.

Saad was the difference in the Bombers’ tight win. His ability to lock down on the opposition’s best small forwards while also bursting off them to set up goals is a rare talent. He may be heading towards more time in the midfield, but he has a key role in stopping Hunt for his side on Sunday.

Tip: Melbourne need to give a much better all-round performance to come away with any points here. Essendon aren’t in sparkling touch, but they have enough star quality and consistency over the ground to pull away. Bombers by 27.

Jayden Hunt (right) and Tom McDonald (left) will need to be at their best on Sunday (AAP)

Fremantle v Port Adelaide

Sunday 6.10PM

Metricon Stadium

The final game of Round 3 will be the first neutral one. Hub inhabitants Fremantle and the Power will square off. It’s lucky no fans are allowed in, as none would attend anyway.

The Power are setting the trend early, and are looking to remain unbeaten. However, Freo have proven they are a hard team to beat; if it were for more luck, they may have gotten two wins from the first two rounds.

Will Port Adelaide’s youth continue to step up?

Port Adelaide’s fast start to 2020 has centred around the younger draftees in Connor Rozee, Zak Butters, Xavier Duursma and Todd Marshall. They have all been up in the best players, and have taken the load off Robbie Gray and Justin Westhoff to consistently perform.

They are the key for the Power, as with them they are a balanced and dangerous team. With fringe players like Stevie Motlop also contributing massively, Port Adelaide need consistency to prove they are a finals contender.

Travis Boak (left)continues to perform in the midfield (AFL)

Who will help out Nat Fyfe and Michael Walters?

The Dockers have star power, but a more even spread is needed if they are to win tight matches. Regardless of how good they are, Fyfe and Walters can’t be everywhere.

James Aish played a handy role in the midfield last week, and may be one part of the solution. Reece Conca is another experienced head who should be chipping in. An improved effort from ruckmen Sean Darcy and Rory Lobb would also go a long way to improving Fremantle’s chances.

Can Michael Walters weave some more magic? (AAP)

Tip: Fremantle are capable of staying with the Power for large portions of the match, but Port Adelaide should be too good. Power by 35.

AFL 2020 Round 2 Review – Adelaide and the Dogs are in trouble, but Port and Gold Coast take giant leaps forward

Well that didn’t go as expected.

From the moment the siren rang out over an otherwise quiet MCG on Thursday night, there was something different about this round of footy. Sure, it was always going to be unusual due to the COVID-19 enforced circumstances. No crowds, fake sounds and the removal of many standard behaviours (such as linking one’s arms to sing a team song after a hard-fought win) meant round two is one that’ll go down in the history books/

With premiership fancies Richmond and Collingwood screeching to a low-scoring draw, the Thursday night result opened up the top of the ladder for a few teams. Some staked their claims for a precious finals spot, while other teams bounced back from the ten week break atrociously, and paid a crushing price for their poor preparation. After just two rounds, there are teams under the pump; a shortened season only means sides can be booted out of top eight contention earlier. The pressure is well and truly on.

Collingwood 5.6 (36) drew with Richmond 5.6 (36)

There was a wide range of tips and predictions made before these two heavyweights clashed for their MCG blockbuster match-up. Only Shane Crawford was on the money when ruefully suggesting the teams were so similarly skilled that a draw could play out. But even Crawf wouldn’t have expected a deadlock so frustrating and low scoring.

After a fast start, Collingwood slipped into a patch of sloppiness. Richmond settled, and both teams were led ably by their defences. Jeremy Howe and Bachar Houli dictated terms, with only Tom Lynch being able to get any kind of reward on the scoreboard with three goals.

A controversial score review on a Jack Higgins mark and goal in the shade of three-quarter time is set to stir up a storm during the week, as the money and effort poured into the system had little impact on a poor decision. But it had no impact on a tepid last term where neither side could consistently crack through for a goal. The Magpies, against all odds, had one last shot at a winning score, but it was to no avail as the siren signalled the first draw between the two proud clubs since 1917. And it wasn’t pretty.

Collingwood

The Pies can take plenty of positives and negatives out of this match-up.

Firstly, their opening term, and parts of their second quarter, were superb. They ran hard, passed skilfully and pressured the reigning premiers into submission. Their goals came as a result of intensity and poise. Nathan Buckley and his diminished coaching staff would be rapt with the progress of Josh Daicos, who had an impressive game off half-back and in spurts through the midfield. Both Brown brothers also provided some speed that stood out in the eye-sore of the second half.

Darcy Cameron was good in parts. He can certainly take a mark, and didn’t look out of place against the league’s best defence. Below his knees he struggled, but for a black and white debut he provided some food for thought for when Mason Cox returns to full fitness.

Scott Pendlebury, Taylor Adams and Steele Sidebottom were in their usual strong form. Pendlebury started off wonderfully but tapered off with his disposal efficiency in the second half. In key moments during the final quarter his usual silky skills were a tad rusty, but the champion still racked up 31 touches.

The only concern for Collingwood would be their bottom players. In a second half where the side stopped running and lapsed into old poor habits, Josh Thomas, Jamie Elliott and Will Hoskin-Elliott were unsighted. Elliott is an exception, for his talent and X-factor demands a consistent place in the side. But with Jaidyn Stephenson and Travis Varcoe waiting in the wings to play a similar role up forward, the other two would need to give a better showing in future games if they are to retain their spot.

Collingwood’s Brodie Grundy wrestles with Ivan Soldo in the ruck

Richmond

The Tigers had a shocking start to their return.

A side who usually pride themselves on a high level of intensity from the get-go, they fell behind quickly to their more determined black and white clad opponents. Dustin Martin was uncharacteristically quiet, only working his way into the game in spurts during the last quarter. Cotchin willed himself into contests, but alongside Martin and Dion Prestia, the midfield had their colours lowered, and turned the ball over when in possession.

Jack Riewoldt was blanketed by Darcy Moore, and his one shot at glory in the last minutes saw his 35-metre set shot fall short. It was unprecedented for Jack. The likes of Jason Castagna, Marlion Pickett and Daniel Rioli also struggled to touch the ball much, and couldn’t create the chances at goal required to get the four points.

In a more upbeat note, Tom Lynch picked up from where he left off in 2019 with three goals. His presence kept his side in the game, and gave Jordan Roughead a headache. Bachar Houli was superb off half-back. He showed his importance to a successful Richmond side, as his rebound and follow-up efforts kept his team in the match throughout most of the first half. Dylan Grimes didn’t touch the ball much, but did superbly in halting Jordan De Goey and Jamie Elliott. All in all, Richmond’s defence held firm and gave the 2019 premiers two extra points then they probably deserved.

And Jack Higgins returning to footy and kicking goals is always a pleasant sight for Richmond fans.

Verdict: Both sides were rusty, but showed signs that they will be leading forces in 2020.

Geelong 17.6 (108) defeated Hawthorn 7.5 (47)

For the first half of this match, the two sides seemed destined for another notorious close finish. A change of scenery down to Geelong had done nothing to disinterest the Hawks, who recovered from a slow start to stick their head in front during stages of the second term. Only a goal down at the main break, a calamity of a second half ruined Hawthorn’s confidence, and allowed Geelong to push up the ladder.

The Cats were impressive, and it was their bit-part players who stood up. Brandan Parfitt came back from the lay-off sporting a new hairstyle and a trimmer physique. His change reaped rewards – he combined with Quinton Narkle to dominate the midfield. Gryan Miers proved he was ready to take another step up as a small forward in 2020, while Rhys Stanley temporarily alleviated some of Geelong’s fears regarding the main ruck position with a commanding effort against Jonathon Ceglar.

Combined with Pat Dangerfield in his 250th game, the renaissance of Gary Ablett Jnr and the evergreen Joel Selwood, Geelong turned it on in the last two quarters to regain some form after a disappointing round one loss. Hawthorn, with Jaeger O’Meara a late out due to injury, faltered after half time. They looked slow, and were toothless in attack without Jon Patton clunking telling marks against the likes of Harry Taylor and Mark Blicavs.

Joel Selwood gets yet another kick away in a superb performance (Quinn Rooney/ Getty Images)

Geelong

Cats fans can breathe out a huge sigh of relief.

Their opening round loss to the Giants doesn’t look as bad now that they are on the board for season 2020. Their defence was superb – Tom Stewart and Mark Blicavs look as good as they have ever been, and that’s saying something for the pair that took 2019 by storm. Joel Selwood hasn’t lost a beat, while younger players are steadily beginning to improve. Two goals from Rhys Stanley is a huge bonus, but it will take a month of consistent output before the AFL world confirms his prowess.

Pat Dangerfield’s kicking for goal has always been dubious, and some shocking set shot misses in his milestone game proved his one flaw. It mattered little in this match, but his wayward accuracy could come to haunt the Cats in clutch moments.

Geelong is now a team on the up. They have a favourable run to start off the season, with numerous more games to be held down at GMHBA Stadium. If they can continue to get improvement from their inexperienced members and Stanley, they may find themselves quickly rising into top four calculations.

Hawthorn

For such a bright start, the second half did everything it could to wipe away Hawthorn’s previous efforts.

Round one was a solid victory over Brisbane. The Hawks looked rejuvenated with some new additions. Chad Wingard was injury-free and dynamic in the middle. Tom Mitchell’s return promised lots alongside O’Meara. Patton, combined with Mitchell Lewis, had the potential to reignite the days of Buddy and Roughead.

In different conditions, Hawthorn fought hard to get back into the game. Mature heads in Burgoyne and Stratton calmed their teammates and methodically picked through Geelong’s assured defence. At the main break, the Hawks had every chance at snatching another win.

But then all structures broke down. There was no speed in the midfield to match Narkle and Parfitt. Patton couldn’t take a mark. Sicily struggled to handle the high amount of forward 50 entries by the Cats. Alastair Clarkson scratched his head, out of answers for the first time in ages. The brown and gold buckled, and are now resigned to a week of scrutiny.

Verdict: Geelong proved they are once again one of the top sides, but still need consistent output from their lesser names. Hawthorn now head back to the drawing board, looking to find a spark that’ll reignite their side that is littered with potential.

Brisbane 12.9 (81) defeated Fremantle 10.9 (69)

It was a heart-stopping finish at the Gabba on Saturday afternoon. Eventually, Brisbane pulled free to avoid an embarrassing home loss against the plucky Dockers.

Ultimately faring better than their cross-town rivals when it came to acclimatising to Queensland, Fremantle stayed with last year’s finalists throughout the entire day. With their youthful side producing spurts of solid football, Fremantle ground the match down to the final minutes. From there, Brisbane’s firepower stood up. The star factor is the only thing Freo are missing if they are to take another step forward in their development. Luckily, Nat Fyfe and Michael Walters are enough of a handful, and their combined efforts in the second half nearly dragged the purple haze over the line.

Lachie Neale starred in his side’s narrow win over Fremantle (Bradley Kanaris/ Getty Images)

Brisbane

The Lions come out of this win with mixed feelings.

One question I asked before the match was whether Lachie Neale and Charlie Cameron could recreate their 2019 form. The answer was an emphatic yes. If it weren’t for these two, the Lions would have gone down comfortably. Cameron was electric, lighting up the first half with four majors. For someone of his size, he is so hard to stop no matter how the ball enters the forward 50. Neale was Brisbane’s barometer, bustling out of packs with pace and making himself dangerous in front of centre. His two goals were impressive and very much required. Alongside Harris Andrews, who controlled the back half, Brisbane’s leading players did enough to get their team over the line.

Eric Hipwood was relatively quiet except for a goal in the opening minute of the third term. He still has the habit of fading out of games quickly. For someone who can take a match by the scruff of the neck, he needs to begin doing it more often if Brisbane are to improve as a side. Without him, Daniel McStay can’t be the only forward target. The Lions rely way too much on Cameron and Oscar McInerney in their attacking set up, but the pair continue to do enough when it matters.

It was a rusty re-start for the Lions, but a win gets them on the board. They will face sterner challenges, but for this week they can be satisfied, for they have given themselves a shot at returning to the top eight.

Charlie Cameron launches into another celebration on Saturday (Jono Searle/ AFL Photos/ Getty Images)

Fremantle

The Dockers have a fair bit to be proud about.

They fought incredibly hard in this match, and made a top four team from last season go up a gear in the final minutes to beat them. That is a sign of improvement from last year – Justin Longmuir is on the right track.

Nat Fyfe started slow, but warmed up to his dominant best. He willed himself into the contest, and hit the scoreboard to cash in his domineering efforts. Michael Walters suggested he may be heading for a more dynamic midfield role this season. He did it all in both the middle and down forward, where two late goals in quick succession nearly catapulted the Dockers to a win.

Matt Taberner presented lots, and did a serviceable job on Harris Andrews. His main issue was his kicking at goal – too often he misses gettable shots, and it doesn’t do his hard work justice. There’s a lot to like about him, but the key for him and his side is conversion.

James Aish started off solidly against his first club. At Collingwood he was used off half-back. In a team without Bradley Hill, Aish filled in on the wing and in the middle with aplomb. He was measured, assured and smart. Fremantle may have just picked up a bargain. With David Mundy in his twilight years, Aish could be the player who fills his role as a classy controlling presence in the middle. Now, they just need a forward line capable of converting their growing midfield.

Verdict: A big sigh of relief for Brisbane, but they still need their fringe players to lift. Fremantle should take heart out of their performance, and strive to snatch a maiden win for season 2020 in the coming weeks.

Carlton 7.11 (53) defeated by Melbourne 8.6 (54)

What an interesting match this was.

Melbourne dominated everything early, their fleet-footed band of smaller players running amuck at Marvel Stadium. Carlton had no way of getting into the game, and fell seven goals behind during the second term. Luckily, Melbourne couldn’t maintain the intensity, and nosedived horribly during the second half. If it wasn’t for skipper Max Gawn, they would have lost this match in the last five minutes. Carlton flicked a switch after half time, and played with pace and freedom.

But when the game was on the line, Carlton’s leaders failed to convert. Both Eddie Betts and Pat Cripps missed multiple shots that would have given the navy blue a win. Yet they wilted under the pressure of the fake crowd noise, and spoiled a golden opportunity to run over the top of the inconsistent Demons.

Max Gawn flies against Carlton’s Marc Pittonet on Saturday evening

Carlton

This is a game that should be split into two halves for the Blues.

Carlton forwards celebrate a goal that came too little, too late (Michael Willson/ AFL Photos via Getty Images)

Their first half was atrocious. They had no reasonable excuse for starting as poorly as they did, and were made to pay. Liam Jones was too often exposed against the pace and nous of Jayden Hunt, and couldn’t keep up with him. Cripps, for all of the talk surrounding him in the past ten weeks, was off. Marc Murphy tried his best to guide Carlton through, but even the elder statesman struggled to inspire his teammates.

But after half time they exploded. Cripps steadily increased his influence. Jack Martin did similar things to round one, yet also contributed up the ground. His dash through the middle and half-forward was so valuable, and allowed Betts to make hay in the pocket. Mitch McGovern was the catalyst – he was such a talent at the Crows, but has only given an indication of what he is capable of in spurts at Carlton. His second half was one such peak – now his challenge is to piece it together more often.

Once again it was good to see Sam Docherty back out on the park. He was rusty, like many of his teammates, but his class off half-back was still evident. It was a disappointing loss, and one that they may come to rue in the coming weeks.

Melbourne

If ever a side needed a ‘get out of jail free’ card, it was Simon Goodwin’s.

They played an aggressive brand of free-running football to set up what should have been a comfortable win, only to drop the ball and allow Carlton passage right back into the contest. They didn’t deserve the win, yet fell over the line. With this slice of luck, they need to capitalise in the next few rounds.

Christian Petracca and Clayton Oliver celebrate a lucky win (AAP/ Scott Barbour)

Hunt, Christian Petracca and Clayton Oliver all shone. The young trio took steps towards reclaiming their 2018 form. Petracca mixed his time in the middle and down forward, using his strong hands and muscular frame to trouble Carlton’s defenders. But his aerobic capacity in the middle was impressive, and signalled a new notch on his belt.

Luke Jackson needs time to develop his craft, yet Tom McDonald couldn’t take the responsibility for him. Alex Neal-Bullen looked more dangerous than he did throughout the entire 2019 season. But the key for Melbourne is consistency. They now have the defence to give them a shot in most games. But forward of centre is where the problem lies, for they only have one Gawn.

Verdict: A valuable win for Melbourne, who must take this lifeline with both hands if they are to avoid the spotlight. Carlton need a win to atone for this, for they are good enough to trouble most teams.

Gold Coast 14.6 (90) defeated West Coast 6.10 (46)

There were some upsets on the weekend, but none rivalled this.

Gold Coast, after a pathetic round one loss, blitzed through premiership fancy West Coast with ease. Controlling the match in the early stages, they dashed away from the Eagles in the second half through a young midfield brigade who outworked West Coast’s deadly centremen.

Matt Rowell demolished the Eagles in just his second game of AFL footy (Chris Hyde/ Getty Images)

Gold Coast

If you need an emphatic win, Gold Coast showed how to do it.

They won their first match for over a year in style, cruising past the 2018 premiers with ease. Their early draft picks shone – Rowell is already showing his worth in just his second match. Anderson is up there with him. Alex Sexton wasn’t required. It was a new-look side.

Touk Miller blanketed Tim Kelly. Every line on the field for the Suns held their own, and presented a strong resistance that is seldom seen from Gold Coast.

The key now is to not get carried away. This season is one where the Suns could get on a roll if they find the key to consistency. They will get plenty of home games, and the Queensland hub should only work in their favour. But now the question is whether their young stars can prove this isn’t a one-time thing. It’s an exciting week ahead for Gold Coast. Could the tables be about to turn?

West Coast

Maybe they were lethargic, or lazy, or cocky. But the Eagles have come crashing down to earth, and face a sobering reality check if they are to recover and bounce back.

These types of losses always hurt. But in a shortened season, they bruise and haunt the losing team. West Coast were poor in many ways. Their highly fancied midfield refused to work hard, and lacked an ounce of class when they did rarely get their hands on the footy. Their potent forward line was out of sync. Nothing went right. It was what they deserved for putting up such a poor effort.

Oscar Allen was one minor shining light. He continues to develop, and is a necessity for the Eagles in a world where Kennedy continues to slow down. Other than that, the real disappointment lay with West Coast’s established premiership players, who should’ve done better than to rock up to Metricon Stadium with such a content mindset.

Verdict: What a win for the Suns, who are promising to finally come along in their development as a club. West Coast face a do-or-die week, for they must win if they are to regather their form.

West Coast players languish yet another Gold Coast goal (Dave Hunt/ AAP)

Port Adelaide 17.8 (110) defeated Adelaide 5.5 (35)

Port Adelaide stamped their finals intentions on the competition by dismantling a Crows side who are crashing down to the foot of the ladder. With 2,000 fans braving a cold Adelaide night to cheer on their teams, the Power turned this into a one-sided contest early.

With an even team effort, Port Adelaide quickly got ahead of Adelaide, and then put the foot down to inflict some serious pain on the Crows. Ken Hinkley’s top eight goal now looks more realistic than ever, while Adelaide have a lot of development to do before they become a force again.

Port Adelaide

It was everything the Port fans wanted to see and more.

The experienced hands of Travis Boak, Charlie Dixon, Brad Ebert, Tom Rockliff and Justin Westhoff were all as industrious as usual. But it was the X-factor burst from Zak Butters, Xavier Duursma, Stevie Motlop, Todd Marshall and Connor Rozee that decisively won this match for the Power. Their audacious draft pick-ups last season are bearing rich fruit. Rozee could have easily won the best on ground medal despite only picking up 17 touches and a goal, for his impact was Cyril Rioli-esque in terms of sudden moments of genius. Butters is already looking a better player than 2019, while Duursma continues to go from strength to strength.

Justin Westhoff sets up another attack for his rampant Port Adelaide teammates (AAP)

Todd Marshall is what the Power are crying out for to accompany Dixon down forward, and to support Lycett in the ruck. With Marshall coming along, the Power will feel no impact of the loss of Patty Ryder. For the first Showdown in a long time, Robbie Gray wasn’t required to control proceedings if the Power were to win. Not since the exciting prospect of the Burgoyne brothers has Port Adelaide possessed such dangerous young players, and it could be the start of a golden era for the Power.

Adelaide

On the other hand, the Crows are in real danger.

With Rory Sloane injured, Adelaide need someone to step up. Rory Atkins, Kyle Hartigan and a plethora of other players from the 2017 Grand Final were real let-downs. Ben Crocker barely got a chance up forward, yet kicked a goal to prove he can be a handy option in attack.

Taylor Walker still got booed despite crowd restrictions, and played poorly. No senior member stood up. Trading Sam Jacobs to GWS may have been a hasty decision. The Crows coaching staff will be looking to the Crouch brothers to lead a charge, while Darcy Fogarty is still the future of the club. But he may have to go through some tough times in the coming seasons if this performance was anything to go by.

Verdict: The Crows were an embarrassment, and are in real danger of a horror 2020 season. The Power are on the opposite end of the spectrum, and now have the talent and belief to shoot for a finals spot.

GWS 8.12 (60) defeated by North Melbourne 12.8 (80)

If Saturday night wasn’t crazy enough, the Kangaroos kicked off Sunday with an early stunning upset against the 2019 Grand Finalists.

With Ben Cunnington under close attention from Matt de Boer, it was Shaun Higgins and a bunch of tough young Roos who stood up to pressure the Giants into submission. GWS were well off the pace, and did well to fight for as long as they did. But it all proved too much in the final minutes, as North Melbourne proved they have some guts – this determination may see the successful Shinboner spirit return.

GWS

It was the exact opposite of round one.

Instead of out classing their opponents, the Giants struggled to fall into any rhythm. They were blanketed by North Melbourne’s plan of restricting them to a boring kick down the line contest. In brief spurts the home side managed to release Lachie Whitfield in space – in these instances, the Giants scored heavily and looked dangerous. But these moments were few and far between. In the end, it was a lack of effort that lost them this game.

Jeremy Cameron is a concern. He couldn’t shake Robbie Tarrant, and it was only Jeremy Finlayson who stood up. Toby Greene didn’t have his usual impact. Stephen Coniglio and Callan Ward relished the tough gameplay, but neither could match it with the Roos for long enough.

It’s no panic stations for the Giants, but it’s a worrying sign to see them so easily bumped off the ball. They have the talent – it’s the intensity they lack to win that maiden flag.

North Melbourne

This match was vindication for Rhyce Shaw’s new game plan.

His young players in Cam Zurhaar, Tarryn Thomas and Jy Simpkin all shone. They all have a touch of X-factor, and are reliable performers who always go hard at the ball. Ben Brown was reasonably quiet, but it was a good sign to see the Roos find avenues to goal around him. It’s the sign of a maturing team.

Shaun Higgins played his best game in a long time, dictating proceedings in the middle and looking fit. His ball use was first class on a weekend characterised by sloppy efficiency. Josh Walker is a wonderful addition down back, while Todd Goldstein is still one of the best ruckmen in the league.

If they sneak another early win, these Roos could be pushing for a finals spot.

Verdict: A snag in the road for the Giants, who will recover but need to find their spark soon. North Melbourne will challenge every side, for they possess a manic intensity that no team can match.

North Melbourne’s Jasper Pittard ensures his GWS opponent can’t mark the ball on Sunday (Brendon Thorne/ AAP)

Sydney 11.7 (73) defeated by Essendon 12.7 (79)

It was another nail-biting instalment of this underrated rivalry.

There was no post-climbing, but Sydney’s youthful brigade fought back late to nearly snatch it from Essendon. The Bombers looked the better team for most of the contest, until they rested on their laurels and nearly lost the unlosable. If it wasn’t for a terrific last quarter by the blooming Darcy Parish, the Swans may have been the unbeaten team instead of the red and black.

Sydney

Plenty to like, but plenty to be frustrated about.

The Swans could easily be 2-0, for they had many chances to snatch a win. Tom Papley and Isaac Heeney were uncharacteristically quiet, leaving it to Josh Kennedy and Luke Parker to will their team back into the contest. Nick Blakey looked slow and a bit behind, meaning the Swans had no avenue to goal without Franklin. They need to lower their eyes inside forward 50, or else every team will pick off their high balls at will.

But they played an incredibly young team, and there can only be upside. Ollie Florent had a down day, and he can only accompany his teammates in lifting that extra gear needed to record a win. Their time may not be now, but John Longmire is building something at Sydney.

Andrew McGrath was at his speedy best on Sunday (Phil Hillyard/ News Corp Australia)

Essendon

Unlike the Swans, Essendon got through the match with a courtesy of younger plays full of poise.

Zach Merrett was a stand-out in the middle, and was ably helped out by Dylan Shiel to give Kennedy and Parker hell. But Andrew McGrath and Darcy Parish injected real pace into the Bombers’ midfield, and were the catalyst of the majority of their goals. Parish’s last quarter goal was remarkable. It capped off a superb final term by the youngster, who is coming into his own as a handy midfielder who is dangerous up forward.

Adam Saad was one of the lone reasons the Bombers managed to hold off the Swans. His bounce off half-back all day was vital – his long booming left foot a weapon used to bypass Sydney’s defensive structures.

What would be of concern for the Bombers is the form of some older players. Dyson Heppell and David Zaharakis barely touched the ball, and looked way too slow for the level. They may be underdone, but it’s worrying signs for Essendon if their veterans are starting to slow down already. Anthony McDonald-Tipungwuti also started off strong before drifting out of the game. He has the talent to become a powerhouse forward, but his inconsistency has let him down plenty of times throughout the years.

Verdict: Essendon got away with a scare, and need to continue building. Sydney are promising, but tacky around the edges.

St Kilda 14.4 (88) defeated the Western Bulldogs 7.7 (49)

Going into the final clash of the round, this match could’ve gone either way. Then, St Kilda proved themselves worthy, and the Bulldogs collapsed in a heap.

St Kilda

The Saints were brutal, and much better than their round one effort. Jack Billings was the star with three goals in a brilliant display. But he was ably supported by his new recruits in Dan Butler and Zak Jones. The Saints looked slick and played with pace. Tim Membrey is an important cog up forward, while Max King continues to come along. Rowan Marshall did his thing with Paddy Ryder in the ruck. Everything was rosy for those drive-in fans.

Dan Hannebery showed why he was recruited, controlling the match and giving a masterful display all around the ground. His skill and poise really stood out. Hunter Clark and Jack Steele continually evolve as handy players for the Saints.

Now off the mark, St Kilda have a big test against the Pies. It may be a difficult match, but they’ll go in full of confidence.

St Kilda’s Zak Jones streaks away from Lin Jong during his side’s great win (The Herald Sun)

Western Bulldogs

Luke Beveridge is now in the hot seat.

For all of their promise, the Bulldog bark held no bite. Aaron Naughton was covered up forward and Josh Bruce couldn’t shoulder the burden for him. Marcus Bontempelli tried his best, but his midfield were way too slow to keep up with the speedy Saints. No one could stop Bradley Hill. Alex Keath was frustrated by the lack of help he received against King and Membrey.

The Bulldogs are a bit of a rabble. They need to cobble together some belief and work to achieve that tenacity that got them into the finals last season. Without it, they are just another mundane side to be walked over.

Verdict: St Kilda may be the season’s big improvers. The Bulldogs, unless they change drastically, are only moving in one direction.

Design a site like this with WordPress.com
Get started